Below is a curated list of 10 home insurance brokers and brokerages serving Indiana. Each of these firms is dedicated to providing homeowners with personalized service, competitive rates, and comprehensive coverage options. Whether you’re looking for local expertise or innovative insurance solutions, these companies have a proven track record in the Hoosier state.
Aldridge Insurance
Based in Indianapolis with multiple locations throughout central Indiana, Aldridge Insurance has been serving Hoosiers for over 30 years. They work with multiple carriers including Liberty Mutual, Travelers, and Cincinnati Insurance. Their specialty lies in bundling home and auto insurance for maximum savings, and they offer specific packages for historic homes and high-value properties.
Baldwin Insurance Group
Operating from Fort Wayne with a strong presence across northern Indiana, Baldwin Insurance Group specializes in comprehensive home insurance coverage. They’re known for their detailed home insurance reviews and their expertise in flood insurance coverage. Their agents are particularly skilled at helping homeowners understand complex policy terms and coverage options.
Covenant Insurance Group
Headquartered in Carmel with offices throughout the Indianapolis metropolitan area, Covenant Insurance Group has established itself as a leader in personalized insurance solutions. They specialize in custom coverage packages for both traditional and luxury homes, and offer unique programs for smart homes and eco-friendly properties. Their team includes certified property specialists who provide detailed risk assessments and tailored coverage recommendations based on advanced analytics.
Gregory & Appel Insurance
One of Indianapolis’s oldest insurance brokerages, Gregory & Appel has been serving Indiana since 1884. They offer comprehensive home insurance solutions and specialize in high-value home coverage. Their risk management team provides detailed property assessments and customized coverage recommendations.
Indiana Farm Bureau Insuranceyyy
Though not strictly a broker, Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance works through a network of local agents across the state. They offer comprehensive home insurance coverage and are particularly known for their excellent claims service and local presence in rural communities. Their agents are familiar with specific regional risks and coverage needs.
Insurance Management Group
Based in Marion but serving all of Indiana, Insurance Management Group represents over 20 insurance carriers. They specialize in creating customized home insurance packages and offer expertise in flood and earthquake coverage. Their technology platform allows clients to compare multiple quotes simultaneously.
ONI Risk Partners
With offices throughout Indiana, ONI Risk Partners provides sophisticated insurance solutions for homeowners. They work with multiple premium carriers and specialize in high-value homes and unique properties. Their risk management team offers comprehensive property assessments and detailed coverage recommendations.
Schultheis Insurance
A family-owned brokerage based in Evansville, Schultheis Insurance serves southern Indiana with comprehensive home insurance solutions. They excel in finding coverage for coastal properties near the Ohio River and have specific expertise in flood insurance. Their agents provide detailed annual policy reviews and claims assistance.
The Thompson Group
Located in Indianapolis with satellite offices across the state, The Thompson Group offers comprehensive home insurance solutions. They work with multiple carriers to find the best coverage and rates for their clients. Their specialty lies in insuring luxury homes and providing risk management services for high-net-worth individuals.
WalkerHughes Insurance
With multiple locations across Indiana, WalkerHughes Insurance provides comprehensive home insurance solutions through their network of experienced agents. They specialize in bundled insurance packages and offer expertise in covering homes of all values. Their technology platform allows for easy policy management and claims filing.
Note: Coverage options, rates, and availability may vary. It’s recommended to contact multiple brokers to compare offerings and find the best fit for your specific situation. Additionally, all brokers listed are licensed to operate in Indiana and are in good standing with the Indiana Department of Insurance as of 2024. Remember that insurance needs vary based on factors such as home location, value, and specific risks.
