Moving to Buffalo, NY: What to Know

New York, Real Estate
Table of Contents Show

Buffalo, New York offers an affordable cost of living, rich history, and a tight-knit community feel. Before making the move, it’s important to understand key aspects of life in Buffalo – from housing and schools to weather and taxes. 

Buffalo is more affordable than many U.S. cities, especially compared to other parts of New York. Overall expenses in Buffalo are below the national average. In fact, Buffalo’s cost of living has been estimated around 5–17% lower than the U.S. average.

Housing costs are a big factor in Buffalo’s affordability. Home prices and rents are significantly cheaper than national figures. Everyday expenses like groceries, utilities, and healthcare also tend to be below the U.S. average.

At the same time, taxes can be higher, as is common across New York. But overall, Buffalo provides a comfortable cost balance. One state analysis even called Buffalo “one of the most affordable places to live in the U.S.”

To put it in perspective, living in Buffalo costs about 24% less than the New York State average (largely due to NYC) and a few percent less than the national average. Whether you’re buying groceries or paying rent, Buffalo’s affordability is a major draw for families and young professionals alike.

Demographics

Demographics, Buffalo, NY
Home Stratosphere
  • College friendliness: 57.25
  • Family friendliness: 26.21
  • Young singles appeal: 56.27
  • Retirement friendliness: 36.46
  • First-time homebuyer friendliness: 25.52
  • Vacation home appeal: 0.00

Buffalo demonstrates moderate appeal for college students and young singles, likely reflecting local colleges and a youthful social environment. However, low ratings for family friendliness and first-time homebuyer friendliness indicate potential challenges regarding affordability or family-oriented amenities. Retirement friendliness is also relatively low, suggesting fewer amenities or attractions for retirees. The absence of vacation home appeal confirms Buffalo as a more residential or urban-focused rather than recreational area.

Lifestyle

Lifestyle, Buffalo, NY
Home Stratosphere
  • Luxury living: 44.02
  • Hip & trendy factor: 80.45
  • Quietness: 32.50
  • Nautical/boating lifestyle: 0.00
  • Urban sophistication: 51.30
  • Walkability: 80.91
  • Car friendliness: 70.53
  • Cycling friendliness: 8.29
  • Vibrancy/liveliness: 73.79
  • Public transit friendliness: 0.00

Buffalo stands out for its high hip & trendy appeal, walkability, and vibrancy, indicating a lively urban environment with significant cultural and social activities. Car friendliness is also relatively high, balancing pedestrian-friendly infrastructure with good road accessibility. However, cycling friendliness and public transit score poorly, highlighting significant gaps in transport infrastructure. The moderate scores in luxury living and urban sophistication suggest a mid-range, comfortable urban lifestyle rather than an upscale or highly sophisticated setting.

Housing Market Trends

Median home prices over time, Buffalo, NY
Home Stratosphere | Zillow Home Values Index

Buffalo’s housing market is relatively affordable and stable. The region didn’t see the extreme price surges that hit some U.S. cities, which makes buying a home in Buffalo attainable for many. As of recent reports, the median home price in the Buffalo area is around $220,000. That’s well below the U.S. median (which is often around $400,000) and even cheaper than other “affordable” metros like Hartford or Louisville.

Market Strength

YoY Home Price Change, Buffalo, NY
Home Stratosphere | Zillow Home Values Index

Buffalo’s housing market experienced moderate fluctuations early in the 2010s, with minor dips followed by steady growth starting from 2013. Particularly strong growth from 2016 onward peaked notably in 2021 with a nearly 17% jump, indicating increased demand and market revitalization. Subsequent years have shown consistently strong but gradually slowing appreciation, suggesting a mature yet still appealing market. Overall, Buffalo demonstrates significant potential for real estate investment, driven by urban revitalization, increased livability, and affordability relative to other urban areas in New York State.

Renting is likewise cheaper than in most cities. Buffalo’s average rent is below the national average, and you can often find a one-bedroom or two-bedroom in the city for significantly less than in coastal metros. Whether buying or renting, housing in Buffalo is a bright spot for your budget.

Home Types and Architecture

Buffalo’s housing stock includes many early 20th-century houses with character – from Victorian and Craftsman styles in neighborhoods like Elmwood Village, to brick doubles and bungalows common on the West Side. There are also newer suburban-style developments in areas just outside the city. About 41% of Buffalo’s residents are homeowners (lower than the 64% U.S. average).

Safety By Neighborhood

Like many cities, Buffalo experiences some crime, but safety can vary widely by neighborhood. Overall, the city’s crime rates are higher than national averages for both violent and property crimes. For instance, Buffalo’s violent crime rate is roughly 2–2.5 times the U.S. average in recent data.

It’s important to note that crime is not uniform across the city. Some neighborhoods are much safer than others. Areas such as Elmwood Village, North Buffalo, and parts of South Buffalo are known for lower crime and a strong community presence, whereas sections of the East Side have historically seen higher crime rates.

Buffalo’s police and community groups are working to improve safety, and violent crime has decreased significantly over the past decade (over 30% lower since the mid-2000s according to city data). Still, Buffalo in recent years ranked among the higher-crime mid-sized U.S. cities, so it’s wise to be aware of your surroundings and seek local insight on safe areas.

Overall, most residents live safely day-to-day, but if you’re moving to Buffalo, it’s a good idea to research specific neighborhoods. On the upside, many Buffalo neighborhoods have a strong community spirit and watch out for each other, which can help enhance safety despite the citywide statistics.

Education Options

Education in Buffalo is a mixed picture, with a range of public and private options. Buffalo Public Schools serve the city’s children, and there are also charter schools, private and parochial schools, and strong suburban districts in the surrounding areas of Erie County.

The Buffalo City School District has made progress in recent years, but it still lags behind state averages on some metrics. For example, the district’s high school graduation rate is around 78–79%, which is an improvement from years past but below the New York State average (roughly 86% statewide).

Buffalo’s public schools face challenges with student poverty and performance scores. On state exams, Buffalo’s proficiency rates in math and reading are well below the New York average. However, there are bright spots: several Buffalo public schools (including criterion schools and specialized programs) achieve strong results and offer Advanced Placement or International Baccalaureate programs. For instance, City Honors School and Hutchinson Tech are examples of city high schools with good reputations.

Private Schools and Suburban Options

Parents considering a move might also look at private schools in Buffalo. The city has longstanding private institutions such as Canisius High School (a Catholic prep school) and Nardin Academy, as well as various charter schools.

Just outside the city, suburban districts like Williamsville, Amherst, and Orchard Park have some of the highest-performing public schools in Western New York – these districts often boast graduation rates around 90% and strong test scores.

Higher Education Hub

For higher education, Buffalo is a major college town. The region is home to several colleges and universities, most notably the University at Buffalo (UB) which is the flagship of the SUNY system. Other colleges include Buffalo State College (SUNY Buffalo State), which is in the city and focuses on arts, education, and liberal arts, and smaller schools like Canisius College, D’Youville University, Medaille University, and Erie Community College.

Easy Commuting

One thing new residents often appreciate about Buffalo is how easy the commute is. The Buffalo area has shorter commute times than almost any other large metro in the country. The typical one-way commute for Buffalo workers is only about 20 minutes, compared to the U.S. average of roughly 26–27 minutes. In fact, a recent analysis named Buffalo the “best metro for commuters” in the U.S. due to its short travel times and low congestion.

Most people in Buffalo drive their own cars, and the region’s highway network makes it easy to get around. Interstate 90 (the New York State Thruway) runs by the city, connecting Buffalo to Erie, Pennsylvania and Rochester/Syracuse to the east. Interstate 190 spur goes into downtown and north to Niagara Falls. Parking is generally easy and affordable.

Public transportation exists, though it’s limited compared to larger cities. The Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority (NFTA) operates Metro Bus lines throughout the city and suburbs, and a single-line Metro Rail that runs along Main Street from downtown to the University at Buffalo’s South Campus. Overall, only about 3% of workers in the Buffalo area commute by public transit, reflecting the car-centric culture.

For longer trips, Buffalo has a convenient airport. The Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) is located about 11 miles east of downtown and is easily accessible by highway. Despite its moderate size, it’s quite well-served – around 100 nonstop flights depart daily to about 30 destinations.

Economic Transformation

Buffalo’s economy has transformed over the years from its industrial past to a more diversified mix today. Once a manufacturing powerhouse, it experienced decline in the late 20th century as factories closed. In recent decades, however, Buffalo has seen growth in healthcare, education, banking, and technology sectors. Health care and social assistance, education, and services now make up over 40% of Buffalo’s workforce.

The job market in Buffalo is stable, though not as fast-growing as Sun Belt cities. Unemployment in the Buffalo metro area has generally tracked close to the national rate. In late 2024, for example, Buffalo’s unemployment was around 4%–5%, comparable to the U.S. average. Wages in Buffalo are decent but not high; the region’s median household income is about $48,000, which is well below the U.S. median (around $80,000). Lower living costs offset some of that.

There’s been growth in fields like biomedical research (with the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus expanding downtown) and customer service/tech support centers. Start-ups and small businesses also play a role, often with support from state initiatives like the “Buffalo Billion” investment plan that sought to rejuvenate the economy.

Common fields include healthcare (nurses, technicians, doctors), education (teachers, professors), engineering (especially mechanical or aerospace), finance and banking, and government.

Healthcare Hub

Buffalo serves as a major healthcare hub for Western New York. Residents have access to numerous hospitals, clinics, and specialists, often without long wait times or travel. The city’s largest healthcare providers include Kaleida Health (which runs Buffalo General Medical Center, Women & Children’s Hospital, etc.) and Catholic Health (which operates Mercy Hospital, Sisters of Charity Hospital, and others).

Buffalo General Medical Center (Kaleida) is a top hospital in the region – it was ranked #1 in the Buffalo metro area and among the top 20 in New York State by U.S. News & World Report. It’s rated “high performing” in multiple adult procedures and conditions, indicating quality outcomes.

For a city its size, Buffalo has excellent specialized care. Notably, Roswell Park Comprehensive Cancer Center is located in Buffalo and is one of the premier cancer research and treatment centers in the country.

In terms of quality, Buffalo’s hospitals have earned respectable marks. For example, several area hospitals have received “A” grades in patient safety in recent years. Buffalo’s healthcare costs (for services) tend to be slightly lower than the U.S. average, which is a bonus.

Tax Considerations

Taxes are an important factor in New York State living. In Buffalo, you’ll encounter New York’s state taxes, which are known to be on the higher side, as well as local property and sales taxes.

Income Tax: New York State charges a progressive income tax. For middle-income households, the state income tax rate is typically between about 5% and 6.5% of income. Higher earners pay more – the top state bracket is around 10% for very high incomes. Importantly, Buffalo does not have a separate city income tax.

Sales Tax: In Erie County (where Buffalo is located), the combined sales tax rate is 8.75%. This includes the New York State base rate of 4% and the local county add-on of 4.75%. Groceries and medicine are exempt from sales tax in NY.

Property Tax: Property taxes in the Buffalo area are high relative to home values – this is a common situation across New York State. The effective property tax rate in New York averages around 1.6%, nearly double the U.S. average of ~0.9%. In practical terms, if you buy a house in Buffalo for, say, $200,000, you might pay on the order of $3,000–$4,000 per year in property taxes.

Rich Cultural Amenities

Olmsted Park
Shutterstock

Buffalo may surprise newcomers with its rich array of amenities, culture, and recreation. The city offers much more than its rust-belt image of the past might imply.

Olmsted Parks System

Buffalo is famous for its beautiful park system designed by Frederick Law Olmsted, the same landscape architect behind NYC’s Central Park. The city has a network of green spaces including six major parks and seven parkways interconnected in Olmsted’s plan. The crown jewel is Delaware Park, a large central park (350+ acres) featuring a lake, golf course, zoo, and trails.

The waterfront has also been revitalized: Canalside and the Buffalo Outer Harbor offer walking paths, concerts, kayaking, and winter ice skating.

Arts and Culture

Culturally, Buffalo punches above its weight. The city’s art museum – the newly expanded Buffalo AKG Art Museum (formerly Albright-Knox) – holds a world-class modern art collection and recently reopened in 2023. It even earned a spot on TIME’s “World’s Greatest Places” list after drawing over 300,000 visitors in its first year since expansion.

Buffalo also boasts the Buffalo Museum of Science, the Buffalo History Museum, and smaller galleries. For performing arts, the city has a vibrant theater scene: Shea’s Performing Arts Center is a lavish 1920s theater downtown that hosts Broadway touring shows. The Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra, based at Kleinhans Music Hall, offers classical and pops concerts year-round.

Culinary Scene and Local Specialties

Buffalo wings
Shutterstock

Buffalo’s food scene is both comforting and innovative. The city is world-famous for Buffalo wings – crispy chicken wings dunked in spicy sauce, invented here in 1964. Buffalo has its own regional specialties, such as beef on weck (a roast beef sandwich on a salted kummelweck roll) and sponge candy (a sweet local treat).

Buffalo’s craft brewery scene has exploded, with places like Big Ditch Brewing and Resurgence Brewing offering great beer in lively taprooms.

Sports Town

Buffalo is a big sports town with passionate fans. The city is home to the NFL’s Buffalo Bills and the NHL’s Buffalo Sabres, as well as the Buffalo Bisons, a Triple-A baseball team. Bills games at Highmark Stadium are a regional ritual – the team has a devoted following known as the “Bills Mafia.”

Four Distinct Seasons

Buffalo’s climate is one of four distinct seasons, with cold, snowy winters and pleasant, warm summers. Being in upstate New York near Lake Erie, Buffalo is firmly in the snow belt – so winter weather is a defining part of life here!

Winter Snow Capital

Winter in Buffalo NY
Shutterstock

Winters in Buffalo are cold and snowy. Average January temperatures are around a high of 31°F (-0.5°C) and a low of 19°F (-7°C). Snowfall is abundant: Buffalo averages about 95 inches of snow per year, which is roughly 8 feet! This is much higher than the U.S. average (which is around 28 inches).

Thanks to lake-effect snow, Buffalo can get heavy snowstorms when cold winds blow over the warmer lake water, dropping intense snow bands. Practically speaking, residents get very good at snow removal. The city and suburbs have fleets of plows, and people invest in snowblowers or hire plowing services for their driveways.

Comfortable Summers

Summers in Buffalo are mild to warm and generally comfortable. Average July temperatures are around 80°F (27°C) for a high, and about 62°F (17°C) for a low. You get plenty of sunny days, and while there are hot stretches, it’s less humid and hot than much of the U.S.

Summer is when Buffalo shines – residents take full advantage of the nice weather with outdoor concerts, festivals, and patio dining. The humidity is moderate and nights cool off, which is great for sleeping.

Spring and Fall Transitions

Spring can be slow to start – March is often still wintry. By April and May, temperatures rise (50s and 60s °F) and the snow melts, but spring is also the rainiest season.

Fall is a beautiful season in Western New York. September and early October have crisp, clear weather (highs in the 60s°F) and the fall foliage in the region can be stunning with reds and oranges. Autumn is usually comfortable, though by November it gets colder and the first snow typically arrives by mid-to-late November.

In summary, Buffalo’s weather requires some resilience, especially in winter, but it also brings many rewards. Many who relocate here come to appreciate the four seasons. Just be ready to invest in a quality snow shovel (or two) and enjoy the adventure of the occasional snowstorm.

References

Related Posts