10 Secluded Neighborhoods Set Up Along the Shorelines of Indiana’s Lake Communities

Indiana may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of lake life, but that’s precisely the point. Along quiet roads and wooded hollows, tucked behind cornfields and small-town diners, are lakefront neighborhoods that stay off the radar—and like it that way. In Nineveh, Lamb Lake Estates stretches out beneath a canopy of old hardwoods, where pontoons drift by like thoughts and the loudest noise you’ll hear is the clink of a fishing rod. Prince’s Lakes isn’t far, but it feels like another world, dotted with cabins, private docks, and a rhythm better measured in oar strokes than minutes.

These neighborhoods aren’t just remote; they’re intentional. They’re what happens when people carve out space from the ordinary and build a life around water, trees, and silence. Some, like Cordry-Sweetwater, are wrapped in conservancy. Others, like Lake Hart, hold onto histories as quietly as they hold onto their shorelines.

Indiana’s lake country has always flown under the radar—less glossy than Michigan, less crowded than Wisconsin—but its beauty is plainspoken and real. It doesn’t ask to be discovered. It just is.

10. Prince’s Lakes: Hidden Retreat in Johnson County

Princes Lakes is a quiet and peaceful Nineveh Township, Johnson County, Indiana community. With a population of under 1,500 residents, this small neighborhood is known for collecting 14 private lakes, making it a hidden retreat for those seeking lakeside living.

The area offers a range of outdoor activities, including fishing, kayaking, and leisurely boat rides. While there are no major industries within Princes Lakes, many residents work remotely or commute to nearby towns.

The sense of seclusion comes from the private roads and the wooded areas surrounding the lakes, ensuring a serene and unspoiled environment. Residents enjoy having their escape, tucked away from the busier parts of the county.

Where is Prince’s Lakes?

Prince’s Lakes is situated in Nineveh Township, just south of the small town of Trafalgar. This secluded community is surrounded by dense woodlands and smaller country roads, enhancing its sense of privacy.

To get there, travelers can take State Road 252 from Trafalgar and follow local roads leading directly to the lakes. The remote setting and limited access points help maintain the area’s quiet and peaceful charm.

9. Lake Hart: A Hidden Gem

Lake Hart offers a tranquil retreat for those seeking a quiet lifestyle. This unincorporated community, formerly incorporated, is characterized by its serene atmosphere and close-knit residents. With a population of just over 200 during its peak, Lake Hart provides a sense of intimacy and belonging that larger towns often lack.

The lake itself is a peaceful haven for recreational activities such as fishing, kayaking, and birdwatching. Its heart-shaped outline adds a unique charm to the area, making it a memorable spot for visitors and locals alike. The surrounding landscape of woodlands and farmland enhances the natural beauty, creating an ideal environment for relaxation and outdoor pursuits.

Lake Hart’s community is steeped in history, having transitioned from an incorporated town to a Conservancy District in the late 20th century. This change reflects the residents’ commitment to preserving the area’s natural resources and maintaining its tranquil character.

Where is Lake Hart?

Lake Hart is located southwest of Mooresville, Indiana, and is less than 30 miles from Indianapolis. Its proximity to the city allows residents and visitors to enjoy the benefits of rural living while still having access to urban amenities. The lake is easily accessible via local roads, making it a convenient yet secluded destination.

The surrounding area includes small towns and scenic countryside, offering a blend of charm and practicality. Nearby attractions such as parks and local eateries provide additional opportunities for leisure and exploration. Despite its accessibility, Lake Hart remains a quiet retreat, away from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Whether you’re looking for a peaceful place to live or a serene spot to visit, Lake Hart’s unique blend of natural beauty and community spirit makes it a standout destination in Indiana.

8. Indian Lake: A Peaceful Escape in Lawrence

Indian Lake is a small, peaceful neighborhood located northeast of Indianapolis, in Lawrence. The community is centered around a 60-acre reservoir and features a population well below 5,000, adding to its quiet charm. Popular activities include fishing, canoeing, and scenic walks along the water’s edge.

While there are no large industries within Indian Lake, the area attracts those seeking a calm, residential lifestyle with easy access to nearby urban amenities.

The wooded surroundings and minimal through traffic create an atmosphere of privacy and relaxation. It’s a place where residents can enjoy the best of both worlds — natural beauty and proximity to city life.

Where is Indian Lake?

Indian Lake is located in Lawrence, just northeast of Indianapolis, tucked along the bend of the White River. This secluded neighborhood is bordered by densely forested areas, which help shield it from the busier parts of the city.

To reach Indian Lake, take Fall Creek Road and follow the smaller residential streets leading to the lake. The hidden nature of these roads contributes to the area’s tranquil and private ambiance.

7. Lake Clearwater: Serenity by the Water in Indianapolis

Lake Clearwater is a charming lakefront community on the north side of Indianapolis, just south of 82nd Street and Dean Road. With a small population and upscale residential properties, it provides a peaceful environment for those seeking waterfront living.

Residents can enjoy kayaking, paddleboarding, and quiet sunset walks along the lake. There are no major industries here, as it primarily serves as a residential retreat, though nearby Keystone Crossing offers a variety of shopping and dining options.

The limited number of homes and the exclusive nature of the community create an air of serenity, making it a hidden gem in the city.

Where is Lake Clearwater?

Lake Clearwater is nestled in Indianapolis, close to the Keystone Crossing area but set apart by its lakeside charm. Despite its proximity to urban conveniences, the neighborhood’s quiet streets and private waterfront properties ensure a sense of seclusion.

Accessing Lake Clearwater involves taking 82nd Street and turning onto Dean Road, leading into the peaceful enclave. The blend of easy city access and tucked-away charm makes this a highly desirable secluded neighborhood.

6. Oxbow Lake: A Hidden Gem in Broad Ripple

Oxbow Lake is a secluded area bordering Broad Ripple, nestled along a curve of the White River. With a small, tight-knit population, this neighborhood offers a peaceful lakeside setting within an otherwise vibrant part of Indianapolis. Activities include fishing, kayaking, and nature walks along the river and surrounding trails.

While no prominent industries are in the neighborhood, its proximity to Broad Ripple’s local businesses means residents can enjoy solitude and community amenities. The natural barrier the river and wooded areas create adds to its sense of privacy, making Oxbow Lake feel like a hidden gem.

Where is Oxbow Lake?

Oxbow Lake lies near Broad Ripple, bordering the White River and surrounded by lush green spaces. Its secluded feel comes from the river’s natural curves and the dense tree lines that separate it from busier streets.

To visit, take Broad Ripple Avenue and head towards the Monon Trail, with local roads guiding you into this peaceful lakeside retreat. The neighborhood’s natural beauty and quiet charm make it a standout in the Indianapolis area.

5. Lake Holiday: Tranquility Near Crawfordsville

Lake Holiday is a private, serene lake community near Crawfordsville, offering sizable lots and natural landscapes. Home to around 250 residents, it provides a quiet environment ideal for families and retirees. The lake’s calm waters are perfect for kayaking, fishing, and paddleboarding.

The surrounding woodlands offer hiking trails and wildlife viewing opportunities, with birdwatching being a popular pastime. The absence of urban noise and light pollution allows for stunning stargazing on clear nights, adding to the area’s tranquil charm.

Where is Lake Holiday?

Situated in Montgomery County, Lake Holiday is just northwest of Crawfordsville. Accessible via State Road 47 and County Road 450 North, the lake is nestled in a rural setting that enhances its secluded feel.

Its proximity to Shades State Park and Turkey Run State Park makes it an excellent location for nature enthusiasts. Despite being a short drive from Crawfordsville’s amenities, Lake Holiday remains a peaceful enclave away from the hustle and bustle.

4. Heritage Lake: Quiet Lakeside Living in Coatesville

Heritage Lake is a secluded community west of Indianapolis, known for its rolling hills, large properties, and extensive natural areas. With a population of approximately 3,000 residents, it combines the benefits of a sizeable community with the peace and privacy of rural living.

The 320-acre lake is the heart of the neighborhood, offering boating, fishing, and swimming opportunities. Residents enjoy community events and amenities like parks and a marina, all while surrounded by the serenity of nature. Hidden fishing spots and quiet picnic areas make Heritage Lake a cherished refuge.

Where is Heritage Lake?

Located in Putnam County, Heritage Lake is near the town of Coatesville. It is accessible via US Highway 36 and County Road 725 East, making it a convenient yet secluded destination.

The area’s geography features gentle hills and lush woodlands, contributing to its tranquil atmosphere. The drive from Indianapolis takes about 45 minutes, offering a quick escape from the city to the peacefulness of lakeside living.

3. Lake Santee: Peaceful Retreat in Rural Greensburg

Lake Santee is a private lake community nestled in the rural surroundings of Greensburg, Indiana. With around 800 residents, it offers an expansive setting with large lot sizes and a strong sense of community. The 250-acre lake provides ample opportunities for boating, fishing, and swimming.

The surrounding undeveloped land ensures a quiet and peaceful environment, with walking trails and wildlife sightings adding to the charm. Regular community events bring residents together, fostering a friendly atmosphere amid the tranquility of nature.

Where is Lake Santee?

Situated in Decatur County, Lake Santee is east of Greensburg and can be reached via State Road 3 and County Road 880 East. The lake’s rural setting is characterized by rolling farmland and patches of woodland, adding to its secluded charm.

Despite its peaceful seclusion, Lake Santee is just an hour’s drive from Indianapolis and Cincinnati, making it an accessible retreat for those looking to escape city life.

2. Cordry-Sweetwater Lakes: Twin Gems of Seclusion

The Cordry and Sweetwater Lakes area is a pair of private lakes offering secluded, wooded neighborhoods in the heart of southern Indiana. Home to approximately 1,500 residents, the communities are known for spacious lots nestled among the trees, abundant wildlife, and a serene environment far from city life.

The crystal-clear waters of the lakes are perfect for swimming, boating, and fishing. The surrounding forests provide ample hiking and nature exploration opportunities, with hidden waterfalls and scenic overlooks awaiting discovery.

The area’s natural beauty and tranquility make it a sought-after destination for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle.

Where is Cordry-Sweetwater Lakes?

Located in Brown County, the Cordry-Sweetwater Lakes community is near Nineveh. Accessible via State Road 135 and Cordry Park Road, the area is about an hour’s drive south of Indianapolis.

The hilly terrain and dense forests of Brown County provide a picturesque backdrop for the lakes, enhancing the secluded feel of the neighborhoods. The journey to Cordry-Sweetwater Lakes takes you through Indiana’s scenic hardwood forests, setting the stage for the awaited tranquility.

1. Lamb Lake Estates: A Forested Haven in Nineveh

Lamb Lake Estates is a private, secluded community surrounded by dense forests in Nineveh, Indiana. With around 200 residents, this neighborhood offers large one-acre lots that provide ample privacy and space. The 500-acre Lamb Lake is a central feature, offering pristine waters for boating, fishing, and swimming.

The tranquil lakefront living experience is complemented by the abundant wildlife and serene atmosphere. Community parks and nature trails offer residents additional opportunities to immerse themselves in the natural beauty that surrounds them.

Where is Lamb Lake?

In Johnson County, Lamb Lake Estates is approximately 35 miles south of Indianapolis. Access is via State Road 135 and Lamb Lake Road, winding through the scenic landscapes of southern Indiana.

The surrounding dense forests and rolling hills contribute to the picturesque geography, making it a secluded haven. Despite its remote feel, the community is within an hour’s drive of Indianapolis, providing a balance between seclusion and accessibility.