I’ve analyzed data from the Zillow Home Value Index to uncover the most expensive residential markets across Ohio. What I found was fascinating – the Buckeye State showcases remarkable diversity in its luxury housing markets, with premium communities clustered around major metropolitan areas like Cleveland, Columbus, and Cincinnati.
My analysis reveals that Ohio’s high-end real estate market has experienced tremendous growth over the past decade, with several upscale communities seeing home values more than double since 2011. This substantial appreciation isn’t just limited to the traditional wealthy enclaves around Cleveland – Columbus suburbs are showing particularly impressive growth trajectories, with towns like Bexley and Grandview Heights seeing increases exceeding 135% since 2011.
What particularly stands out is the dramatic acceleration in recent years. While Ohio has historically been considered an affordable housing market nationally, its premium communities are showing appreciation rates that rival traditionally “hot” coastal markets. The twin luxury communities of Hunting Valley and The Village of Indian Hill stand in a class by themselves, with average home values approaching $1.5 million – nearly triple the values found in many other top-25 communities across the state.
25. Sugarcreek
- 2025 Home Value: $487,223
- 2020 Home Value: $352,496
- 2015 Home Value: $295,991
- 2011 Home Value: $269,763
- % Change 2011-2025: 80.61%
- % Change 2015-2025: 64.61%
- % Change 2020-2025: 38.22%
Homes in Sugarcreek average $487,000, up significantly by 38% since 2020. Located near Dayton, this community blends upscale suburban living with scenic countryside charm. Strong recent appreciation signals increasing desirability among affluent buyers. Excellent schools further drive demand. Investing here ensures consistent financial growth and suburban prestige.
24. Hudson
- 2025 Home Value: $496,894
- 2020 Home Value: $346,603
- 2015 Home Value: $295,262
- 2011 Home Value: $270,292
- % Change 2011-2025: 83.84%
- % Change 2015-2025: 68.29%
- % Change 2020-2025: 43.36%
Hudson homes average nearly $497,000, marking 84% growth since 2011. Situated between Akron and Cleveland, Hudson’s historic charm and quality amenities consistently attract high-end buyers. Recent rapid appreciation reflects growing market strength. Its picturesque setting and excellent schools sustain premium valuations. Property here offers long-term financial stability..
23. Dry Run
- 2025 Home Value: $501,645
- 2020 Home Value: $345,575
- 2015 Home Value: $283,140
- 2011 Home Value: $281,826
- % Change 2011-2025: 78.00%
- % Change 2015-2025: 77.17%
- % Change 2020-2025: 45.16%
Dry Run homes average around $502,000, increasing significantly by 45% since 2020. East of Cincinnati, this community offers scenic properties with suburban accessibility. Recent rapid growth underscores strong demand. Excellent schools enhance attractiveness to families. Investing here provides solid returns and upscale suburban tranquility.
22. Grandview Heights
- 2025 Home Value: $504,169
- 2020 Home Value: $391,133
- 2015 Home Value: $271,085
- 2011 Home Value: $214,337
- % Change 2011-2025: 135.22%
- % Change 2015-2025: 85.98%
- % Change 2020-2025: 28.90%
Homes average $504,000 in Grandview Heights, surging an impressive 135% since 2011. Adjacent to downtown Columbus, its walkable streets and vibrant culture attract affluent urbanites. Rapid appreciation highlights continued desirability. Historic charm blends seamlessly with modern amenities. Owning here ensures exceptional financial appreciation and lifestyle appeal.
21. Orange
- 2025 Home Value: $511,395
- 2020 Home Value: $368,049
- 2015 Home Value: $315,812
- 2011 Home Value: $294,112
- % Change 2011-2025: 73.88%
- % Change 2015-2025: 61.93%
- % Change 2020-2025: 38.95%
Homes in Orange average $511,000, reflecting strong 39% growth since 2020. Located near Cleveland, this community balances wooded landscapes with urban conveniences, attracting upscale buyers. Premier shopping and top schools drive consistent demand. Controlled development preserves exclusivity. Investment here promises reliable financial returns
20. Amberley
- 2025 Home Value: $525,351
- 2020 Home Value: $337,582
- 2015 Home Value: $262,491
- 2011 Home Value: $243,822
- % Change 2011-2025: 115.46%
- % Change 2015-2025: 100.14%
- % Change 2020-2025: 55.62%
Amberley Village homes average $525,000, doubling in value since 2011 and surging 56% since 2020. This Cincinnati suburb combines upscale living with extensive parkland and spacious lots. Rapid recent appreciation highlights growing market demand among affluent buyers. Its prime location and natural beauty maintain sustained valuations. Property here ensures financial security and lifestyle prestige.
19. Plain City
- 2025 Home Value: $526,184
- 2020 Home Value: $360,555
- 2015 Home Value: $277,969
- 2011 Home Value: $256,183
- % Change 2011-2025: 105.39%
- % Change 2015-2025: 89.30%
- % Change 2020-2025: 45.94%
Plain City homes average $526,000, more than doubling since 2011, with notable 46% growth since 2020. Northwest of Columbus, it provides a rural atmosphere with suburban amenities, attracting buyers seeking spacious properties. Excellent Dublin schools and historic charm enhance desirability. Strategic location ensures continued appreciation. Investing here delivers financial stability and appealing country-suburban balance.
18. Bexley
- 2025 Home Value: $536,817
- 2020 Home Value: $385,233
- 2015 Home Value: $280,900
- 2011 Home Value: $224,895
- % Change 2011-2025: 138.70%
- % Change 2015-2025: 91.11%
- % Change 2020-2025: 39.35%
Homes in Bexley average around $537,000, reflecting an exceptional 139% increase since 2011. Located just east of Columbus, Bexley is renowned for its historic architecture, charming Main Street, and elite schools. Strong appreciation (39% since 2020 alone) underscores continued market desirability. Urban-suburban blend appeals to affluent professionals and families. Property here provides both historical prestige and solid financial growth.
17. Dublin
- 2025 Home Value: $540,570
- 2020 Home Value: $362,731
- 2015 Home Value: $300,415
- 2011 Home Value: $269,012
- % Change 2011-2025: 100.95%
- % Change 2015-2025: 79.94%
- % Change 2020-2025: 49.03%
Dublin’s average home value surpasses $540,000, doubling since 2011 and climbing 49% since 2020. Northwest of Columbus, this vibrant community blends historic charm with modern innovation, attracting corporate headquarters and affluent residents. World-class amenities, top-rated schools, and diverse housing stock sustain robust market demand. Ongoing growth ensures continued financial strength. Investment here secures substantial long-term appreciation potential.
16. Riverlea
- 2025 Home Value: $546,201
- 2020 Home Value: $376,557
- 2015 Home Value: $308,795
- 2011 Home Value: $262,286
- % Change 2011-2025: 108.25%
- % Change 2015-2025: 76.88%
- % Change 2020-2025: 45.05%
Riverlea homes average $546,000, more than doubling since 2011 with 45% growth since 2020. Adjacent to Worthington north of Columbus, this village combines mid-century charm with secluded exclusivity. Limited housing inventory and distinctive neighborhood atmosphere sustain high valuations. Access to excellent Worthington schools enhances market appeal. Property here offers both appreciation and unique community character.
15. Powell
- 2025 Home Value: $546,905
- 2020 Home Value: $382,667
- 2015 Home Value: $318,485
- 2011 Home Value: $275,235
- % Change 2011-2025: 98.71%
- % Change 2015-2025: 71.72%
- % Change 2020-2025: 42.92%
Powell homes average about $547,000, reflecting consistent appreciation and strong 43% growth since 2020. This upscale suburb north of Columbus provides a charming historic downtown and exceptional schools. Affluent developments and controlled growth drive sustained property values. Convenient location and excellent amenities maintain steady demand. Investing here ensures financial stability and family-oriented sophistication.
14. Upper Arlington
- 2025 Home Value: $586,695
- 2020 Home Value: $411,575
- 2015 Home Value: $320,338
- 2011 Home Value: $265,851
- % Change 2011-2025: 120.69%
- % Change 2015-2025: 83.15%
- % Change 2020-2025: 42.55%
Upper Arlington homes average approximately $587,000, doubling in value since 2011 and increasing 43% since 2020. Located northwest of Columbus, this established suburb combines historic homes, top-ranked schools, and proximity to downtown. Community amenities like parks and golf courses reinforce its enduring appeal. Consistent market demand sustains strong appreciation. Property here guarantees both prestige and reliable financial growth.
13. New Albany
- 2025 Home Value: $594,983
- 2020 Home Value: $390,259
- 2015 Home Value: $332,976
- 2011 Home Value: $284,817
- % Change 2011-2025: 108.90%
- % Change 2015-2025: 78.69%
- % Change 2020-2025: 52.46%
Homes average $595,000 in New Albany, demonstrating a remarkable 52% increase since 2020. This meticulously planned suburb northeast of Columbus is renowned for Georgian architecture, premier schools, and sophisticated amenities. Its vibrant business park attracts affluent residents and sustains economic strength. Strategic planning and distinctive community features ensure continued appreciation. Investing here delivers exceptional financial stability and upscale living.
12. Galena
- 2025 Home Value: $601,435
- 2020 Home Value: $410,200
- 2015 Home Value: $338,440
- 2011 Home Value: $290,311
- % Change 2011-2025: 107.17%
- % Change 2015-2025: 77.71%
- % Change 2020-2025: 46.62%
Galena homes average about $601,000, doubling in value since 2011 and increasing nearly 47% since 2020. Located northeast of Columbus, this village offers upscale country living and careful preservation of historic character. Nearby recreation and quality schools enhance its desirability among families. Strategic location and controlled growth maintain premium valuations. Property here ensures steady appreciation in a serene, sophisticated setting.
11. Montgomery
- 2025 Home Value: $604,927
- 2020 Home Value: $411,473
- 2015 Home Value: $322,011
- 2011 Home Value: $309,841
- % Change 2011-2025: 95.24%
- % Change 2015-2025: 87.86%
- % Change 2020-2025: 47.01%
Homes in Montgomery average approximately $605,000, marking significant 47% growth since 2020. This upscale Cincinnati suburb blends historic charm with sophisticated amenities, attracting affluent buyers. Its excellent schools and thriving community events drive sustained market appeal. Central location ensures convenient access to major employment hubs. Montgomery provides a strong financial return and enduring lifestyle advantages.
10. Pepper Pike
- 2025 Home Value: $647,122
- 2020 Home Value: $460,402
- 2015 Home Value: $418,297
- 2011 Home Value: $379,421
- % Change 2011-2025: 70.55%
- % Change 2015-2025: 54.70%
- % Change 2020-2025: 40.56%
Pepper Pike homes average $647,000, experiencing a strong 41% increase since 2020. This affluent Cleveland suburb combines natural beauty, spacious properties, and careful zoning to maintain exclusivity. Excellent schools and private clubs add substantial value. Its convenient location sustains high market demand. Property here remains a secure investment promising long-term growth and stability.
9. Moreland Hills
- 2025 Home Value: $652,995
- 2020 Home Value: $445,250
- 2015 Home Value: $408,103
- 2011 Home Value: $359,970
- % Change 2011-2025: 81.40%
- % Change 2015-2025: 60.01%
- % Change 2020-2025: 46.66%
Homes average about $653,000 in Moreland Hills, rising notably by 47% since 2020. Positioned near Cleveland, this village is known for expansive, wooded estates and preserved rural character. Its strong recent market growth emphasizes growing desirability among high-end buyers. Proximity to urban amenities balances its exclusive setting. Investing here ensures steady appreciation in a sophisticated suburban environment.
8. Terrace Park
- 2025 Home Value: $688,808
- 2020 Home Value: $475,627
- 2015 Home Value: $415,139
- 2011 Home Value: $372,699
- % Change 2011-2025: 84.82%
- % Change 2015-2025: 65.92%
- % Change 2020-2025: 44.82%
Terrace Park’s average home value reaches nearly $689,000, reflecting a significant 85% increase since 2011. Located east of Cincinnati along the Little Miami River, this village offers exceptional historic charm and community atmosphere. Its recent 45% growth since 2020 indicates accelerating demand among affluent buyers. Excellent schools and recreational opportunities further enhance market stability. Property here provides reliable appreciation and family-oriented luxury.
7. Gates Mills
- 2025 Home Value: $708,282
- 2020 Home Value: $499,252
- 2015 Home Value: $463,465
- 2011 Home Value: $437,166
- % Change 2011-2025: 62.02%
- % Change 2015-2025: 52.82%
- % Change 2020-2025: 41.87%
Homes in Gates Mills average around $708,000, up 62% since 2011 and 42% since 2020. Situated in the picturesque Chagrin River Valley, this community combines historic charm with upscale rural living. Its spacious estates and stringent zoning preserve exclusivity. Prestigious local amenities, including country clubs, enhance its appeal. Gates Mills remains an excellent investment offering consistent financial stability.
6. Waite Hill
- 2025 Home Value: $711,825
- 2020 Home Value: $508,252
- 2015 Home Value: $454,563
- 2011 Home Value: $471,215
- % Change 2011-2025: 51.06%
- % Change 2015-2025: 56.60%
- % Change 2020-2025: 40.05%
Waite Hill homes average approximately $712,000, demonstrating strong 40% growth since 2020. Located east of Cleveland, this village prioritizes rural preservation with strict zoning and expansive estates. Lack of commercial development maintains exclusivity and privacy. Rolling landscapes and wooded acreage further elevate its attractiveness. Investment here offers stable appreciation in a secluded luxury market.
5. Kirtland Hills
- 2025 Home Value: $734,856
- 2020 Home Value: $488,851
- 2015 Home Value: $445,093
- 2011 Home Value: $437,559
- % Change 2011-2025: 67.94%
- % Change 2015-2025: 65.10%
- % Change 2020-2025: 50.32%
Homes in Kirtland Hills average about $735,000, with rapid recent appreciation (50% growth since 2020). This village, located east of Cleveland, is renowned for spacious estate properties and careful environmental preservation. Strict five-acre zoning supports exclusivity and sustained property values. The scenic Chagrin Valley setting further enhances desirability. Buying here ensures a secure investment in both lifestyle and financial stability.
4. Marble Cliff
- 2025 Home Value: $747,389
- 2020 Home Value: $563,863
- 2015 Home Value: $441,130
- 2011 Home Value: $336,946
- % Change 2011-2025: 121.81%
- % Change 2015-2025: 69.43%
- % Change 2020-2025: 32.55%
Marble Cliff’s home values have surged to approximately $747,000, marking a remarkable 122% increase since 2011. This compact, historic community near downtown Columbus offers prestigious living and distinctive architecture. Its rapid appreciation (33% since 2020 alone) indicates growing desirability among affluent buyers. Residents benefit from a serene neighborhood atmosphere while remaining close to urban amenities. Property here offers strong financial growth and historic charm.
3. Bentleyville
- 2025 Home Value: $795,846
- 2020 Home Value: $568,206
- 2015 Home Value: $555,999
- 2011 Home Value: $529,116
- % Change 2011-2025: 50.41%
- % Change 2015-2025: 43.14%
- % Change 2020-2025: 40.06%
Bentleyville homes average nearly $796,000, solidifying its position as a top luxury market near Cleveland. The village’s scenic woodland setting, three-acre minimum lots, and absence of commercial zoning reinforce exclusivity. Recent rapid growth (40% since 2020) highlights increasing market desirability. Residents enjoy both privacy and proximity to charming Chagrin Falls. Investing here provides exceptional value growth in a sophisticated rural setting.
2. The Village of Indian Hill
- 2025 Home Value: $1,497,060
- 2020 Home Value: $975,299
- 2015 Home Value: $958,943
- 2011 Home Value: $916,539
- % Change 2011-2025: 63.34%
- % Change 2015-2025: 56.12%
- % Change 2020-2025: 53.50%
Homes in Indian Hill average nearly $1.5 million, reflecting its status as Cincinnati’s premier luxury address. Known for sprawling estates and minimum five-acre zoning, the village combines rural tranquility with proximity to urban amenities. Dramatic 54% appreciation since 2020 demonstrates accelerated demand among affluent buyers. Its strong community planning, exceptional schools, and abundant green space sustain high valuations. Property here represents enduring wealth preservation and exclusivity.
1. Hunting Valley
- 2025 Home Value: $1,497,631
- 2020 Home Value: $1,054,146
- 2015 Home Value: $1,008,019
- 2011 Home Value: $950,878
- % Change 2011-2025: 57.50%
- % Change 2015-2025: 48.57%
- % Change 2020-2025: 42.07%
Home values in Hunting Valley average $1.5 million, making it Ohio’s most exclusive community. This prestigious enclave east of Cleveland features estate properties on large parcels, typically five acres or more, ensuring privacy and exclusivity. Strict zoning prevents commercial development, reinforcing its premium valuation. The area’s longstanding reputation and recent 42% growth since 2020 underscore strong, enduring market demand. Investing here guarantees elite status and stable financial appreciation.
