10 Secluded Neighborhoods Tucked into the Folds of Wisconsin’s Baraboo Hills

In Wisconsin’s Baraboo Hills, the landscape folds in on itself—hills rolling like knuckles under a green quilt, sandstone bluffs weathered to the bone, and valleys stitched with streams that slip past farms, woods, and quiet roads. Here, seclusion feels earned, not imposed. These are neighborhoods that take their time—La Rue, Denzer, Honey Creek—places where the map fades into contour lines and gravel curves, where the sky is bigger because the noise is less.

The Baraboo Range carries the marks of ancient geology and modern restraint. Protected forests edge up against open fields, and cabins tuck themselves into the folds of pine hollows or ridgebacks like Black Hawk. There’s history here, both written and unspoken—in the limestone churches, in the pasture fences running uphill, in the name of a road like Turnipseed. This is a region that attracts those who prefer a dirt driveway over a sidewalk, a screened porch over a deck, and a long walk over a shortcut.

Each of these 10 neighborhoods tells a slightly different story. Some, like Baxter’s Hollow, offer immersion in wildness. Others, like Natural Bridge, share a border with state parks and prehistoric stone. All offer a quiet geography of retreat—where what surrounds you matters as much as what’s missing.

So whether the pull is trout water, wooded acreage, or a farmhouse at the end of a hilltop road, the Baraboo Hills answer with space, rhythm, and just enough mystery to keep you looking around the next bend.

10. Otter Creek – Hidden Streams and Meadows

Otter Creek is a serene enclave where residents live harmoniously with nature. The neighborhood is characterized by properties that offer access to tranquil streams and expansive meadows teeming with wildlife.

With a small population of around 150 people, it’s a place where everyone knows each other, fostering a tight-knit community spirit. Outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy fishing in the clear waters of Otter Creek or hiking through the lush meadows that burst with wildflowers in the spring.

Hidden from the main roads, this area provides a peaceful retreat for those looking to escape the everyday grind.

Where is Otter Creek?

Located in the southeastern part of the Baraboo Hills, Otter Creek sits just north of the village of Rock Springs. Its geography is marked by rolling hills and the meandering streams that give the area its name, offering picturesque landscapes at every turn.

To get there, take County Road DD east from Rock Springs, then turn north onto Otter Creek Road, which winds its way into the heart of the neighborhood. The secluded location means there’s little traffic, so residents and visitors alike can enjoy the quietude of this hidden gem.

9. La Rue – Remote Country Living

La Rue is a hidden treasure within the hills, offering spacious properties in a quiet, low-traffic area distant from city life. With a modest population of about 200 residents, it’s the perfect place for those seeking solitude and a strong connection with the land.

The area is ideal for horseback riding, with numerous trails weaving through the countryside. Local farms and homesteads often offer fresh produce and handmade goods, adding to the community’s rustic charm. The absence of urban noise makes La Rue a sanctuary for relaxation and reflection.

Where is La Rue?

Situated west of the Baraboo Hills, La Rue is tucked away off Highway 136, making it wonderfully remote yet accessible. The landscape is characterized by gentle hills and open fields, providing stunning sunsets and panoramic views.

Visitors can reach La Rue by taking Highway 136 west from Baraboo and then turning onto La Rue Road, which leads directly into the community. The area’s seclusion is amplified by the surrounding farmland and few bordering towns, making it a true escape from the everyday.

8. Black Hawk Ridge – Elevated Privacy

Atop the majestic Baraboo Hills, Black Hawk Ridge offers homes with expansive views and large parcels of land amid nature. Approximately 300 residents enjoy the unique combination of elevation and privacy, with properties often surrounded by dense woods.

The ridge is a haven for birdwatchers and hikers, with trails like the popular Black Hawk Ridge Trail offering breathtaking vistas of the Wisconsin River Valley. The community values conservation, ensuring that the natural beauty remains unspoiled for generations.

Where is Black Hawk Ridge?

Black Hawk Ridge is located northeast of Mazomanie, perched high above the surrounding landscapes. The area is accessible via Highway 78, with a turn onto County Road Y leading up into the hills.

Its elevated position provides stunning views and contributes to its seclusion, as the winding roads discourage traffic. The ridge’s proximity to state natural areas enhances its appeal for those who love outdoor activities in serene settings.

7. Pine Hollow – Quiet Forested Enclave

Surrounded by dense pine forests, Pine Hollow provides secluded homesteads away from main roads and urban noise. Home to around 250 residents, this neighborhood is ideal for those who appreciate the soothing sounds of nature.

The thick canopy of trees offers a sense of enclosure and peace, with properties often featuring rustic cabins or modern homes built to blend with the environment. Hiking, birdwatching, and simply enjoying the woodland atmosphere are daily pleasures for Pine Hollow inhabitants.

Where is Pine Hollow?

Pine Hollow lies south of the Baraboo Hills, between North Freedom and Prairie du Sac. Accessible via Pine Hollow Road off Highway PF, the journey into the neighborhood is marked by increasingly dense forestry.

The area’s interesting geography includes pine forests, small creeks, and valleys that add to its secluded feel. The lack of major transportation routes nearby ensures that Pine Hollow remains a quiet retreat amidst nature.

6. Witwen – Serene Rural Setting

A quaint community along Honey Creek, Witwen offers privacy with its generous lot sizes and peaceful countryside backdrop. With a population of just over 100 residents, it’s a place where rural charm meets natural beauty.

The historic Witwen Campground hosts community events and music festivals, bringing people together to celebrate local culture. Residents often engage in farming, crafts, and outdoor activities, taking full advantage of the area’s fertile land and scenic surroundings.

Where is Witwen?

Witwen is situated northwest of Sauk City, along County Road E. The community is nestled in the scenic Honey Creek valley, which provides a picturesque setting of rolling hills and meandering waterways.

To reach Witwen, take Highway 12 to Sauk City and head west on County Road PF before connecting to County Road E. The area’s serene landscapes and winding roads make the journey a delightful experience, perfectly setting the tone for what Witwen has to offer.

5. Natural Bridge – Living Among Sandstone Bluffs

Adjacent to the Natural Bridge State Park, homes here enjoy expansive properties near sandstone formations and dense forests. Approximately 180 residents have the unique privilege of living amongst some of Wisconsin’s most striking geological features.

Opportunities for hiking and exploring the ancient sandstone arches and cliffs are abundant, offering endless adventures at one’s doorstep. The combination of natural wonder and seclusion makes this neighborhood a coveted spot for nature enthusiasts.

Where is Natural Bridge?

Natural Bridge is located southwest of Leland and is accessible via Highway C. The neighborhood’s proximity to Natural Bridge State Park means protected lands and natural beauty envelop it.

From Baraboo, visitors can take Highway 33 west to Leland and then follow local roads to the area. The sandstone bluffs and rich history of the land, including evidence of some of the earliest human habitation in the region, add layers of intrigue to this secluded locale.

4. Honey Creek – Valley Seclusion

This area offers secluded residences on large lots with lush surroundings along the serene Honey Creek valley. Home to around 220 people, Honey Creek is characterized by its peaceful ambiance and the gentle sounds of the flowing creek.

The valley provides fertile grounds for gardening and agriculture, and local farms often sell fresh produce and artisanal goods. The community values sustainability and harmony with nature, making it an ideal place for those looking to live off the land.

Where is Honey Creek?

Honey Creek is nestled south of Spring Green, with County Road C running through the valley’s heart. The geography features rolling hills and the namesake creek, which creates picturesque scenes throughout the area.

To get there, take Highway 23 south from Spring Green and turn east onto County Road C. The secluded nature of the valley, combined with the lack of major highways, ensures that Honey Creek remains a tranquil haven.

3. Leland – Hidden Hillside Community

Nestled in the Baraboo Hills, Leland features spacious homesteads and a tranquil environment enveloped by natural beauty. With a small population of about 150 residents, it’s a place where time seems to slow down.

The community is known for its annual Frog Hop event, a local tradition that brings families together for fun and festivities. The surrounding hills provide ample opportunities for hiking, wildlife viewing, and enjoying panoramic views of the countryside.

Where is Leland?

Leland is located northwest of Baraboo, accessible via Highway 154. The village is tucked away in the hills, offering a secluded atmosphere that is hard to find elsewhere. From Baraboo, take Highway 33 west and then connect to Highway 154 north.

The winding roads and elevation changes make the journey scenic, with the natural beauty of the Baraboo Hills serving as a constant backdrop. Leland’s hidden location makes it a perfect escape for those seeking peace.

2. Denzer – Countryside Escape

This small rural community provides expansive acre-plus properties amidst rolling hills and farmland, far from urban centers. Denzer is home to around 120 residents who enjoy the simplicity and tranquility of country living.

The area is ideal for agriculture, with many residents engaging in farming and livestock raising. Local parks and nearby natural areas offer spaces for recreation and connecting with nature. Denzer’s tight-knit community is known for its welcoming spirit and communal support.

Where is Denzer?

Denzer is situated southwest of Sauk City, along Highway 12. The area’s geography consists of gentle hills and open fields, characteristic of Wisconsin’s picturesque farmland.

To reach Denzer, take Highway 12 south from Sauk City until you reach County Road C, then head west into the heart of the community. The rural roads and expansive landscapes contribute to Denzer’s secluded feel, making it an ideal destination for those looking to escape the city’s pace.

1. Baxter’s Hollow – Wilderness Retreat

Set within a vast nature preserve, Baxter’s Hollow offers secluded living with large wooded lots surrounded by untouched forestland. With merely 100 residents, it’s the epitome of seclusion and natural beauty.

The neighborhood is adjacent to the Baxter’s Hollow State Natural Area, providing residents with direct access to pristine hiking trails and wildlife observation. The sounds of the forest and the absence of urban noise make it a perfect retreat for nature lovers and those seeking solitude.

Where is Baxter’s Hollow?

Baxter’s Hollow is located northwest of Sauk City, at the end of a narrow valley. Accessible via Highway 12 and then Turnipseed Road, the journey to Baxter’s Hollow is as scenic as the destination.

The area’s interesting geography includes steep hillsides, rocky outcrops, and dense forests, all contributing to its secluded character. The remote location and the surrounding protected lands ensure that Baxter’s Hollow remains a wilderness sanctuary, untouched by the encroachment of city life.