Home Stratosphere readers have been voting on older homes: a heart or a thumbs-down under every photo in our articles about 1950s to 1990s homes, from 1970s kitchens to before-and-after makeovers. We’ve pulled it into one report: 32,762 votes from 5,647 readers on 1,120 photos, plus the reasons readers gave.
The practical old kitchen won

12 of the 15 most-loved photos (at least 50 votes each) show kitchens, and 9 come from one article, 27 Things 1970s Kitchens Got Right That We Should Never Have Gotten…. Rounded counter edges came first (96%); the same article’s warming drawer that kept dinner ready without… (91%), pull-out cutting board hidden right under the… (90%) and lazy susan that made the worst cabinet in the… (88%) are also on the list. Readers loved the old kitchen for what it did.
Same kitchen, 27 redesigns
One article took a single 1990s oak kitchen and showed 27 ways to update it, each photo with the original on top. Because the starting kitchen never changed, the votes compare the redesigns directly. White cabinets with a navy island drew 87% hearts and sage lower cabinets with cream uppers 82%. Black cabinets with a pale maple island drew 14%, and burgundy lower cabinets 17%. When readers explained a thumbs-down on a makeover, the colours came first.
Farmhouse and traditional won; modern lost

Farmhouse (72%) and traditional (62%) rooms drew the most hearts; modern (34%) and Scandinavian (38%) the fewest, and the gap held when we compared each photo with the others in its own article. Our then-and-now pairs, which stack a furnished 1980s room above today’s version, drew just 37%, and the reason readers gave most often for a thumbs-down on them was “Too cold / stark”.
Vinyl plank and shag carpet lost

Engineered wood and vinyl plank floors drew 34%; tile drew 59% and hardwood 54%. Some of the 1970s is better left behind, too: shag carpeting (10%), patterned wall-to-wall carpet (11%) and oversized floral sofas (14%) were among the least-loved photos in the study.
The full report
The Retro Homes Report pools the photos by cabinet colour, countertop, wood tone, floor, style, era and light, ranks the most- and least-loved features and all 27 oak-kitchen redesigns, and shows why readers voted the way they did. It includes the full dataset.
Get the full report at StatwrenHow we did this
- Readers tapped a heart or a thumbs-down under each photo in 34 of our articles about 1950s to 1990s homes between Aug 30, 2026 and Nov 17, 2026. One vote per reader per photo.
- Votes are anonymous: no names, emails or accounts. Readers were reacting to photos, not their own homes.
- Percentages are the share of hearts. Traits such as cabinet colour and countertop were read from each photo; article groupings are ours.
- More on how we collect reader data: How our reader data works.
