Every kitchen below was stuck in its decade: honey oak, avocado appliances, speckled granite, wallpaper borders with geese on them. We gave each one three makeovers. Two are the redesigns you would expect. The third is the wildcard, the one most designers would talk you out of, and it is often the one readers like best.
How it works: tap the photo to step through the makeovers, then vote for the one you would actually live with. You will see how your pick stacks up against everyone else’s.
In order to come up with the very specific design ideas, we create most designs with the assistance of state-of-the-art AI interior design software. Also, assume links that take you off the site are affiliate links such as links to Amazon. this means we may earn a commission if you buy something.
Please note that the images in this article were created with the assistance of AI.
1. The 1990s Honey Oak Kitchen
Orange-toned oak cabinets, white laminate counters and a fluorescent light box in the ceiling. This was the default American kitchen for a decade.
Before
2. The 1970s Avocado Kitchen
Avocado appliances, dark walnut cabinets and harvest-gold counters. Some readers will feel nostalgic. Most will reach for a crowbar.
Before
3. The 1980s Country Goose Kitchen
A wallpaper border of geese in bonnets, pickled oak, and blue-and-white tile counters with dark grout lines.
Before
4. The Faux Tuscan Kitchen
Speckled granite, dark cherry cabinets, travertine and wrought iron. In 2004 this was the dream.
Before
5. The 1950s Pink Tile Kitchen
Bubblegum pink wall tile, metal cabinets and a boomerang laminate counter. It has charm, but it also has rust.
Before
6. The Almond Laminate Kitchen
Almond appliances, white laminate cabinets with blue trim, and blue tile counters. Very 1992.
Before
7. The Dark 1980s Galley
A narrow galley with dark brown cabinets, a dropped ceiling and a single fluorescent tube.
Before
8. The Cracked Linoleum Farmhouse
Mismatched cabinets, a freestanding sink and linoleum that cracked decades ago.
Before
9. The Builder-Grade 2000s Kitchen
Maple cabinets, black granite and a beige tile backsplash. Nothing wrong with it, and nothing to love.
Before
10. The Brick and Orange Kitchen
Wood paneling, a brick accent wall and orange laminate. The 1970s never left.
Before
11. The Southwestern Pine Kitchen
Knotty pine, terracotta tile and turquoise everything.
Before
12. The Oak-Trimmed Melamine Kitchen
White melamine doors with oak edge trim and floral wallpaper.
Before
13. The Pass-Through Window Kitchen
Harvest gold, a pass-through window to the dining room and dark cabinets.
Before
14. The Tiny 1940s Apartment Kitchen
An old enamel stove, peeling paint and almost no counter space.
Before
15. The 1990s Faux Victorian Kitchen
Dark green laminate counters and brass everything.
Before
16. The Soffit Kitchen
Soffits over the cabinets, frosted glass doors and dated tile.
Before
17. The Knotty Pine Cabin Kitchen
Knotty pine on every wall, ceiling and cabinet.
Before
18. The Mosaic Tile Counter Kitchen
Chocolate-brown mosaic tile counters, gingham curtains and cabinets the colour of strong coffee.
Before
19. The Espresso Cabinet Kitchen
Espresso cabinets and a strip of glass mosaic tile. Popular around 2008, very dark today.
Before
20. The Rooster Country French Kitchen
Distressed cream cabinets, toile curtains and a rooster on every available surface.
Before
21. The Windowless Basement Kitchen
Dark paneling, a low ceiling and no windows at all, lit by a buzzing fluorescent tube.
Before
22. The Turquoise Metal Cabinet Kitchen
Turquoise steel cabinets from the 1960s, now chipped and spotted with rust.
Before
23. The Hunter Green and Burgundy Kitchen
Hunter green walls, burgundy accents and an oak island. Very 1996.
Before
24. The Mirrored Backsplash Condo Kitchen
A mirrored backsplash, smoked-glass cabinet doors and black laminate. The 1980s at full volume.
Before
25. The Carpeted Farmhouse Kitchen
Yes, that is carpet. In a kitchen. It happened more than you would think.
Before
Which wildcard surprised you most? The pattern we keep seeing is that the boldest option wins more votes than you would think, as long as the room keeps something warm, like wood, brass or a soft colour.