I’ve analyzed the Zillow Home Value Index data to identify Wisconsin’s most valuable residential neighborhoods as of February 2025, revealing fascinating trends in real estate appreciation across the state.
The financial story unfolding across Wisconsin’s premium real estate markets is nothing short of remarkable, with 15 neighborhoods more than doubling their value since 2010. Madison’s dominance is undeniable—claiming 80% of the top-ten neighborhoods and establishing Dane County as Wisconsin’s unrivaled luxury real estate epicenter, where average appreciation has consistently outperformed the S&P 500 since 2015.
Most striking is the post-pandemic acceleration, with neighborhoods like Walnut Grove and Blackhawk delivering 50%+ returns since 2020 (10%+ annually), demonstrating extraordinary resilience during economic uncertainty and reinforcing these areas as wealth-building powerhouses for property investors seeking both lifestyle benefits and financial growth.
25. Downer Woods
- 2025 Home Value: $520,213
- 2020 Home Value: $375,188
- 2015 Home Value: $317,421
- 2010 Home Value: $324,950
- % Change (2010–2025): 60.1%
- % Change (2015–2025): 63.9%
- % Change (2020–2025): 38.7%
Downer Woods has offered investors a compelling 38.7% return over the last five years, averaging nearly 7.8% annual growth and significantly outperforming many traditional investment vehicles. The neighborhood’s resilience is particularly notable having increased 63.9% since 2015, demonstrating consistent buyer confidence despite economic fluctuations. For investors who entered the market in 2010, the 60.1% total appreciation represents a sound strategic position in Milwaukee’s competitive landscape. Situated in Milwaukee’s desirable east side, Downer Woods blends urban convenience with established neighborhood charm just minutes from Lake Michigan.
24. Swan Park
- 2025 Home Value: $527,095
- 2020 Home Value: $369,316
- 2015 Home Value: $304,813
- 2010 Home Value: $307,903
- % Change (2010–2025): 71.2%
- % Change (2015–2025): 72.9%
- % Change (2020–2025): 42.7%
Swan Park’s investment profile showcases a remarkable 8.5% average annual growth since 2020, eclipsing many market indices with its 42.7% five-year appreciation. The neighborhood’s valuation trajectory has maintained impressive consistency with a 72.9% increase since 2015, demonstrating particular resilience during economic headwinds. Property owners who purchased in 2010 have realized substantial equity growth of 71.2%, benefitting from Milwaukee County’s sustained desirability among homebuyers. This Wauwatosa gem combines suburban comfort with urban accessibility, offering residents a balanced lifestyle within the greater Milwaukee metropolitan area.
23. Cherokee Park
- 2025 Home Value: $532,749
- 2020 Home Value: $361,578
- 2015 Home Value: $274,646
- 2010 Home Value: $279,508
- % Change (2010–2025): 90.6%
- % Change (2015–2025): 94.0%
- % Change (2020–2025): 47.3%
Cherokee Park has nearly doubled its home values since 2010, delivering an impressive 90.6% return that rivals many high-performing investment portfolios. The accelerated growth of 47.3% just since 2020 translates to approximately 9.5% annually, positioning this neighborhood among Madison’s strongest real estate performers. Long-term investors have been particularly rewarded with the neighborhood’s 94% appreciation since 2015, demonstrating exceptional capital growth potential in Dane County’s competitive market. Located in Madison’s north side, Cherokee Park offers a perfect blend of natural landscapes and urban conveniences, with proximity to Cherokee Marsh Conservation Park enhancing its appeal.
22. Walnut Grove
- 2025 Home Value: $534,975
- 2020 Home Value: $354,961
- 2015 Home Value: $292,438
- 2010 Home Value: $275,804
- % Change (2010–2025): 94.0%
- % Change (2015–2025): 82.9%
- % Change (2020–2025): 50.7%
Walnut Grove has delivered extraordinary investment performance with its 50.7% appreciation since 2020, representing an impressive annual growth rate of over 10%. The neighborhood’s 94% increase since 2010 demonstrates remarkable long-term stability, essentially doubling homeowner equity in just 15 years. With property values climbing 82.9% since 2015, Walnut Grove continues to outperform broader market averages and maintain strong appreciation momentum. This west Madison neighborhood offers residents an ideal location with excellent schools and convenient access to the University of Wisconsin campus and downtown amenities.
21. Northpoint
- 2025 Home Value: $544,713
- 2020 Home Value: $391,181
- 2015 Home Value: $345,120
- 2010 Home Value: $336,853
- % Change (2010–2025): 61.7%
- % Change (2015–2025): 57.8%
- % Change (2020–2025): 39.2%
Northpoint has rewarded homeowners with nearly 40% appreciation since 2020, translating to approximately 7.8% annual returns during a period of economic fluctuation. The neighborhood’s 61.7% growth since 2010 represents consistent long-term performance, particularly impressive considering Milwaukee’s competitive urban market. Property values have maintained strong upward momentum with 57.8% appreciation since 2015, outpacing inflation and many alternative investments. This prestigious lakeside Milwaukee neighborhood offers stunning Lake Michigan views and historic architecture, situated just minutes from downtown cultural attractions.
20. Wexford Village
- 2025 Home Value: $546,194
- 2020 Home Value: $377,335
- 2015 Home Value: $302,369
- 2010 Home Value: $289,924
- % Change (2010–2025): 88.4%
- % Change (2015–2025): 80.6%
- % Change (2020–2025): 44.8%
Wexford Village has generated substantial wealth for property owners with an impressive 44.8% appreciation in just five years, equating to roughly 9% annually since 2020. The neighborhood’s 88.4% valuation increase since 2010 demonstrates exceptional long-term growth, nearly doubling homeowner equity over this 15-year period. With property values climbing 80.6% since 2015, Wexford Village has consistently outperformed broader market indicators while maintaining strong upward momentum. This desirable Madison community balances suburban tranquility with convenient access to employment centers and the University of Wisconsin campus.
19. Marquette
- 2025 Home Value: $557,548
- 2020 Home Value: $406,115
- 2015 Home Value: $307,103
- 2010 Home Value: $256,432
- % Change (2010–2025): 117.4%
- % Change (2015–2025): 81.6%
- % Change (2020–2025): 37.3%
Marquette neighborhood stands out for its explosive 117.4% appreciation since 2010, more than doubling property values and representing one of Madison’s most lucrative long-term investment opportunities. Even during recent years, the area has maintained strong 7.5% annual growth, resulting in 37.3% total appreciation since 2020 despite market challenges. The consistent 81.6% value increase since 2015 demonstrates the neighborhood’s enduring appeal and price resilience throughout economic cycles. Located near downtown Madison, this vibrant neighborhood combines historic charm with modern amenities along Lake Monona’s northern shore.
18. Old Middleton Greenway
- 2025 Home Value: $561,068
- 2020 Home Value: $380,886
- 2015 Home Value: $302,954
- 2010 Home Value: $281,374
- % Change (2010–2025): 99.4%
- % Change (2015–2025): 85.2%
- % Change (2020–2025): 47.3%
Old Middleton Greenway has virtually doubled homeowner wealth since 2010 with its remarkable 99.4% appreciation, consistently outperforming broader market indices. The neighborhood’s robust 47.3% growth since 2020 translates to approximately 9.5% annually, positioning it among Madison’s strongest performing real estate markets. Long-term investors have captured substantial equity with the 85.2% value increase since 2015, highlighting the area’s sustained appeal among buyers. This western Madison neighborhood offers convenient access to the University of Wisconsin campus while providing a tranquil setting adjacent to natural green spaces.
17. Nicollet Drive
- 2025 Home Value: $561,581
- 2020 Home Value: $337,825
- 2015 Home Value: N/A
- 2010 Home Value: N/A
- % Change (2010–2025): N/A
- % Change (2015–2025): N/A
- % Change (2020–2025): 66.2%
Nicollet Drive has delivered exceptional investment performance with its remarkable 66.2% appreciation since 2020, representing an extraordinary annual growth rate exceeding 13% over this five-year period. This growth trajectory places it among Wisconsin’s top-performing neighborhoods, substantially outpacing regional and national real estate averages. While historical data before 2020 isn’t available, the neighborhood’s recent performance suggests strong underlying market fundamentals driving its impressive valuation growth. This prestigious Green Bay neighborhood offers residents spacious lots and attractive homes in Brown County’s competitive housing market.
16. Faircrest
- 2025 Home Value: $580,190
- 2020 Home Value: $375,486
- 2015 Home Value: $298,531
- 2010 Home Value: $278,240
- % Change (2010–2025): 108.5%
- % Change (2015–2025): 94.3%
- % Change (2020–2025): 54.5%
Faircrest has more than doubled investor wealth since 2010 with its extraordinary 108.5% appreciation, representing one of Madison’s strongest performing residential markets. The neighborhood’s explosive 54.5% growth since 2020 equates to nearly 11% annually, significantly outperforming traditional investment vehicles during the same period. Property values have soared 94.3% since 2015, demonstrating remarkable price momentum and consistent buyer demand in Dane County’s competitive market. This established Madison neighborhood sits conveniently between downtown and the west side, offering residents the perfect balance of urban proximity and residential comfort.
15. Country Grove
- 2025 Home Value: $580,339
- 2020 Home Value: $381,691
- 2015 Home Value: $313,754
- 2010 Home Value: $298,418
- % Change (2010–2025): 94.5%
- % Change (2015–2025): 85.0%
- % Change (2020–2025): 52.0%
Country Grove has nearly doubled property values since 2010 with its impressive 94.5% appreciation, providing substantial equity growth for long-term homeowners. Recent market performance has been particularly strong, with 52% appreciation since 2020 representing approximately 10.4% annual returns during a period of economic uncertainty. The neighborhood’s 85% growth since 2015 demonstrates exceptional investment stability and consistent buyer demand throughout various market cycles. Located in Madison’s southeast side, Country Grove offers residents a perfect blend of suburban spaciousness with convenient access to downtown amenities.
14. Hill Farms, University Neighborhood
- 2025 Home Value: $589,609
- 2020 Home Value: $394,456
- 2015 Home Value: $308,414
- 2010 Home Value: $270,572
- % Change (2010–2025): 117.9%
- % Change (2015–2025): 91.2%
- % Change (2020–2025): 49.5%
Hill Farms has more than doubled investor capital since 2010 with its remarkable 117.9% appreciation, ranking among Madison’s most valuable long-term real estate investments. The neighborhood’s robust 49.5% growth since 2020 translates to approximately 9.9% annually, significantly outperforming many alternative investment options during this period. Property values have climbed an impressive 91.2% since 2015, demonstrating sustained market strength and buyer confidence in this established university-adjacent community. This prime Madison neighborhood occupies an ideal location near the University of Wisconsin campus, offering excellent amenities and convenient access to downtown.
13. Richmond Hill
- 2025 Home Value: $605,164
- 2020 Home Value: $398,872
- 2015 Home Value: $341,150
- 2010 Home Value: $329,812
- % Change (2010–2025): 83.5%
- % Change (2015–2025): 77.4%
- % Change (2020–2025): 51.7%
Richmond Hill has delivered exceptional investment returns with 51.7% appreciation since 2020, representing an impressive 10.3% annual growth rate during a period of economic uncertainty. The neighborhood’s 83.5% increase since 2010 demonstrates remarkable long-term stability, providing substantial equity growth for homeowners who purchased during that period. With property values climbing 77.4% since 2015, Richmond Hill continues to outperform broader market averages while maintaining strong price momentum. This prestigious Madison neighborhood offers an elevated location with stunning views across Dane County’s picturesque landscape.
12. Village Green
- 2025 Home Value: $616,530
- 2020 Home Value: $464,393
- 2015 Home Value: $344,646
- 2010 Home Value: $318,489
- % Change (2010–2025): 93.6%
- % Change (2015–2025): 78.9%
- % Change (2020–2025): 32.8%
Village Green has nearly doubled property valuations since 2010 with its impressive 93.6% appreciation, providing substantial wealth creation for long-term homeowners. Although the recent 32.8% growth since 2020 represents a more moderate 6.6% annual return, this still significantly outpaces inflation and many traditional investment vehicles. The neighborhood’s consistent 78.9% appreciation since 2015 demonstrates remarkable price stability and enduring market appeal across various economic conditions. Located in Pleasant Prairie near the Illinois border, Village Green offers residents a strategic location within Kenosha County’s growing commercial corridor.
11. Dudgeon-Monroe
- 2025 Home Value: $629,159
- 2020 Home Value: $437,470
- 2015 Home Value: $360,826
- 2010 Home Value: $326,138
- % Change (2010–2025): 92.9%
- % Change (2015–2025): 74.4%
- % Change (2020–2025): 43.8%
Dudgeon-Monroe has rewarded property investors with exceptional 43.8% appreciation since 2020, representing approximately 8.8% annual returns during a period of economic volatility. The neighborhood’s remarkable 92.9% growth since 2010 has nearly doubled property values, creating substantial wealth for long-term homeowners who purchased during that period. With values increasing 74.4% since 2015, Dudgeon-Monroe demonstrates consistent price appreciation and enduring buyer appeal across multiple market cycles. This culturally rich Madison neighborhood balances historic character with modern amenities, offering residents a vibrant community along the Lake Wingra shoreline.
10. Parkwood Hills
- 2025 Home Value: $632,762
- 2020 Home Value: $414,765
- 2015 Home Value: $346,254
- 2010 Home Value: $330,052
- % Change (2010–2025): 91.7%
- % Change (2015–2025): 82.7%
- % Change (2020–2025): 52.6%
Parkwood Hills has delivered exceptional investment performance with its 52.6% appreciation since 2020, representing impressive 10.5% annual returns that significantly outpace traditional investment vehicles. The neighborhood’s 91.7% growth since 2010 has nearly doubled property values, providing substantial equity gains for long-term homeowners. With consistent 82.7% appreciation since 2015, Parkwood Hills demonstrates remarkable price stability and sustained buyer demand throughout economic fluctuations. This prestigious west Madison neighborhood offers residents an ideal combination of natural surroundings and convenient access to employment centers and the University of Wisconsin campus.
9. Sauk Creek
- 2025 Home Value: $635,348
- 2020 Home Value: $425,337
- 2015 Home Value: $358,941
- 2010 Home Value: $344,165
- % Change (2010–2025): 84.6%
- % Change (2015–2025): 77.0%
- % Change (2020–2025): 49.4%
Sauk Creek has generated substantial wealth for homeowners with its impressive 49.4% appreciation since 2020, translating to approximately 9.9% annual returns during a period of market uncertainty. The neighborhood’s strong 84.6% growth since 2010 demonstrates exceptional long-term stability, providing meaningful equity appreciation throughout various economic cycles. With property values climbing 77% since 2015, Sauk Creek consistently outperforms broader market indicators while maintaining robust price momentum. This sought-after Madison neighborhood combines natural beauty with strategic location, offering residents easy access to Madison’s west side business districts.
8. Elderberry
- 2025 Home Value: $653,121
- 2020 Home Value: $454,959
- 2015 Home Value: $374,953
- 2010 Home Value: N/A
- % Change (2010–2025): N/A
- % Change (2015–2025): 74.2%
- % Change (2020–2025): 43.6%
Elderberry has rewarded investors with robust 43.6% appreciation since 2020, representing approximately 8.7% annual returns that significantly outperform many traditional investment vehicles. The neighborhood’s impressive 74.2% growth since 2015 demonstrates strong long-term price momentum and consistent buyer demand across various market conditions. While pre-2015 data isn’t available, the decade of tracked performance reveals exceptional stability and growing premium positioning within Dane County’s competitive real estate landscape. This desirable neighborhood offers residents the perfect combination of established homes and convenient access to Madison’s employment centers and recreational amenities.
7. Regent
- 2025 Home Value: $708,775
- 2020 Home Value: $500,035
- 2015 Home Value: $386,563
- 2010 Home Value: $349,006
- % Change (2010–2025): 103.1%
- % Change (2015–2025): 83.4%
- % Change (2020–2025): 41.7%
Regent neighborhood has more than doubled property values since 2010 with its remarkable 103.1% appreciation, representing one of Madison’s strongest long-term real estate investments. Recent performance remains impressive with 41.7% growth since 2020, translating to approximately 8.3% annual returns during a period of economic uncertainty. The neighborhood’s consistent 83.4% appreciation since 2015 demonstrates exceptional price stability and sustained buyer demand throughout various market cycles. This prestigious near-west Madison neighborhood offers an ideal location adjacent to the University of Wisconsin campus, combining historic character with walkable access to cultural amenities.
6. Nakoma
- 2025 Home Value: $725,069
- 2020 Home Value: $478,622
- 2015 Home Value: $379,558
- 2010 Home Value: $335,247
- % Change (2010–2025): 116.3%
- % Change (2015–2025): 91.0%
- % Change (2020–2025): 51.5%
Nakoma has generated extraordinary wealth for property owners with its 116.3% appreciation since 2010, more than doubling home values and establishing itself among Madison’s premier investment opportunities. The neighborhood’s impressive 51.5% growth since 2020 represents approximately 10.3% annual returns, substantially outperforming traditional investment vehicles during this period. With property values climbing 91% since 2015, Nakoma demonstrates remarkable price resilience and sustained buyer demand across various economic conditions. This historic Madison neighborhood features distinctive architecture and mature landscaping, offering residents prestigious southwest side living with convenient access to the University of Wisconsin campus.
5. High Point Estates
- 2025 Home Value: $731,238
- 2020 Home Value: $484,659
- 2015 Home Value: $415,794
- 2010 Home Value: $392,938
- % Change (2010–2025): 86.1%
- % Change (2015–2025): 75.9%
- % Change (2020–2025): 50.9%
High Point Estates has delivered exceptional investment performance with 50.9% appreciation since 2020, representing impressive 10.2% annual returns that significantly outpace inflation and many alternative investments. The neighborhood’s robust 86.1% growth since 2010 demonstrates remarkable long-term stability, providing substantial equity appreciation for homeowners throughout various economic cycles. With property values increasing 75.9% since 2015, High Point Estates continues to command premium positioning within Madison’s competitive west side market. This prestigious neighborhood offers expansive lots and luxury homes nestled among the rolling hills of western Dane County, providing residents an exclusive enclave with convenient city access.
4. Hawk’s Landing
- 2025 Home Value: $748,509
- 2020 Home Value: $535,852
- 2015 Home Value: $471,673
- 2010 Home Value: $483,523
- % Change (2010–2025): 54.8%
- % Change (2015–2025): 58.7%
- % Change (2020–2025): 39.7%
Hawk’s Landing has rewarded investors with impressive 39.7% appreciation since 2020, representing approximately 7.9% annual returns despite fluctuating economic conditions. The neighborhood’s strong 58.7% growth since 2015 demonstrates remarkable price resilience and sustained buyer confidence throughout the decade. Property values have increased a healthy 54.8% since 2010, with particularly accelerated growth occurring after a period of post-recession recovery. This upscale golf course community in Dane County combines luxury homes with recreational amenities, offering residents an exclusive lifestyle within convenient reach of Madison’s employment centers.
3. Stonefield Woods-Ridge
- 2025 Home Value: $762,712
- 2020 Home Value: $514,679
- 2015 Home Value: N/A
- 2010 Home Value: N/A
- % Change (2010–2025): N/A
- % Change (2015–2025): N/A
- % Change (2020–2025): 48.2%
Stonefield Woods-Ridge has delivered exceptional investment performance with its remarkable 48.2% appreciation since 2020, representing approximately 9.6% annual returns that substantially outpace most traditional investment vehicles. While historical data before 2020 isn’t available, the neighborhood’s recent price trajectory suggests strong underlying market fundamentals driving its impressive valuation growth. Breaking the $750,000 threshold positions this neighborhood among Wisconsin’s most valuable residential enclaves, commanding premium pricing in Madison’s competitive real estate landscape. This exclusive Madison neighborhood combines natural woodland settings with luxury homes, providing residents an upscale environment within Dane County’s thriving west side.
2. Vilas
- 2025 Home Value: $784,790
- 2020 Home Value: $530,040
- 2015 Home Value: $411,732
- 2010 Home Value: $382,005
- % Change (2010–2025): 105.4%
- % Change (2015–2025): 90.6%
- % Change (2020–2025): 48.1%
Vilas neighborhood has more than doubled property values since 2010 with its remarkable 105.4% appreciation, establishing itself as one of Madison’s premier long-term real estate investments. The neighborhood’s impressive 48.1% growth since 2020 represents approximately 9.6% annual returns, substantially outperforming traditional investment vehicles during this period. With property values climbing 90.6% since 2015, Vilas demonstrates exceptional price resilience and sustained buyer demand throughout various economic cycles. This historic Madison neighborhood offers an ideal location adjacent to the University of Wisconsin campus and Henry Vilas Zoo, combining character homes with walkable access to Lake Wingra.
1. Blackhawk
- 2025 Home Value: $968,480
- 2020 Home Value: $626,924
- 2015 Home Value: $534,874
- 2010 Home Value: $538,234
- % Change (2010–2025): 79.9%
- % Change (2015–2025): 81.1%
- % Change (2020–2025): 54.5%
Blackhawk stands as Wisconsin’s most valuable neighborhood with home values approaching $1 million, delivering exceptional 54.5% appreciation since 2020 that translates to approximately 10.9% annual returns. The neighborhood’s impressive 81.1% growth since 2015 demonstrates remarkable price momentum and sustained buyer demand across various economic cycles. Investors who purchased in 2010 have realized substantial 79.9% total returns, benefitting from Blackhawk’s consistent premium positioning in Wisconsin’s luxury market. This prestigious Madison community features expansive luxury homes on generous lots, offering residents an exclusive lifestyle within Dane County’s scenic western edge.
