Home Stratosphere readers have been voting on makeovers: a heart or a thumbs-down under every before-and-after in our room makeover articles, most of which show many redesigns of the same room. We’ve pulled it into one report: 40,894 votes from 6,265 readers on 1,423 makeovers, plus the reasons readers gave.
Same room, opposite verdicts
Because nearly every article redesigns one starting room over and over, the votes compare the redesigns directly, and the spread is huge. Our builder-grade foyer turned French country drew 81% hearts; the same foyer turned into a rainbow statement room drew 2%. In the French country living room article, the best redesign drew 92% and the worst 7%.
From Plain Builder Grade to French Country Grandeur
From Basic Builder Grade to Grand Estate Drama
From Suburban Bland to Industrial Command Center
From Builder Grade Bland to Pink Palace Photo Studio Perfection
From Builder Grade Bland to Mondrian-Inspired Masterpiece
From Beige Boredom to Bold Rainbow Statement Sanctuary
Warm, light and farmhouse won

Farmhouse redesigns drew 58%, Scandinavian 50% and coastal 49%; modern 32%, mid-century 30% and bohemian 22%. Warm-toned rooms drew 43% against 19% for cool ones, light wood beat dark (53% vs 35%), and the gaps held when we compared each photo with the others in its own article.
In the kitchen, cream cabinets

Cream cabinets drew 71%, far ahead of white (43%), natural wood (42%), navy (35%) and black (35%). Soapstone counters (71%) and butcher block (54%) beat quartz and granite.
Stacked Stone Backsplash and Exposed Beams Pull a Plain Kitchen Into…
From Basic Builder Grade to French Country Elegance
Builder-Grade Oak Tomb to Dramatic Navy and Brass Galley Powerhouse
From Honey Oak to Industrial Chic with Subway Tile Drama
Slate Gray Cabinets and Veined Granite Slab Bury a Kitchen That Had…
Open-Plan Afterthought to Defined Kitchen Zone with Full-Height…
The makeovers readers loved most

Fireplace, Dark Beams, and Caramel Leather Made the Room Feel Built…
From Builder-Grade to Warm Wood Contemporary Living Space
From Basic Builder Grade to French Country Elegance
Ceiling Beams, a Fireplace, and Pale Sage Turned Quiet Into Luxurious
From Builder Grade Hallway to Navy Paneled Gallery Wall Masterpiece
Library Ladder and Coffered Mahogany Replace Contractor White
And the ones they rejected
10 of the 15 least-loved makeovers came from our foyers and living rooms “for narcissists”: rainbow, Mondrian, neon and mirror-palace rooms. Black, purple and pink walls scored lowest of any wall colour (20%, 21% and 18%).
From Builder Grade Beige to Golden Geometric Drama
From Builder Grade Blandness to Neon-Lit Gaming Paradise
From Builder Grade Beige to Celestial Blue Cosmic Fantasy
From Beige Boredom to Bold Rainbow Statement Sanctuary
From Builder Grade Bland to Mondrian-Inspired Masterpiece
From Neutral Minimalism to Opulent Ruby Red Drama
The full report
The Makeover Report pools every redesign by style, era, colour temperature, light, wood tone, floor, cabinets, counters, walls and sofa, ranks the best and worst redesigns of the same room, and shows why readers voted the way they did. It includes the full dataset.
Get the full report at StatwrenHow we did this
- Readers tapped a heart or a thumbs-down under each photo in 41 of our before-and-after makeover articles between Feb 19, 2026 and Nov 18, 2026. One vote per reader per photo.
- Votes are anonymous: no names, emails or accounts. Readers were reacting to photos, not their own homes.
- Percentages are the share of hearts. Traits such as style and era were read from each photo; article groupings are ours.
- More on how we collect reader data: How our reader data works.
