20 of the Best Island Towns in the Midwest Offer Unique Adventures

The Midwest may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of island getaways, but nestled among its lakes and rivers are some of the most charming and unique island towns waiting to be explored. From secluded luxury retreats to vibrant party hubs, these islands offer a diverse array of experiences that showcase the heartland’s hidden gems. Join us as we count down the 20 best island towns in the Midwest, each offering its own slice of paradise away from the hustle and bustle.

20. Crane Island, Minnesota: Secluded Luxury on Lake Minnetonka

Tucked away in the sprawling waters of Lake Minnetonka, Crane Island offers an exclusive retreat for those seeking tranquility and elegance. This secluded community is known for its beautiful homes that blend seamlessly with the lush surroundings. With limited accessibility, the island provides residents and visitors with a serene environment perfect for unwinding. The calm waters around the island are ideal for kayaking and paddleboarding, offering picturesque views that make you feel worlds away from the mainland. Homes on Crane Island typically cost between $304,166 and $500,000 for a 3-4 bedroom property, offering a luxurious yet secluded lifestyle.

19. Prairie Island, Minnesota: Heritage Along the Mississippi

Located along the mighty Mississippi River, Prairie Island is home to the Prairie Island Indian Community, a federally recognized Mdewakanton Sioux Indian tribe. Visitors can immerse themselves in the rich cultural heritage by attending traditional powwows or visiting the community center, where stories and traditions are shared. The island’s natural beauty also offers opportunities for bird watching and hiking, with the river providing a serene backdrop to this culturally significant destination. A 3-4 bedroom home on Prairie Island costs between $200,000 and $350,000, blending affordability with a setting rich in heritage.

18. Nicollet Island, Minnesota: A Historic Oasis in Minneapolis

Nestled in the heart of Minneapolis, Nicollet Island is a charming enclave that feels like stepping back in time. The island boasts a historic district filled with beautifully preserved Victorian homes and cobblestone streets. Enjoy a leisurely stroll through the lush Nicollet Island Park, or dine at the iconic Nicollet Island Inn, a boutique hotel offering riverside views and fine dining. It’s a peaceful oasis amidst the urban landscape, offering a unique blend of history and city life. Homes on Nicollet Island range from $600,000 to $900,000 for a 3-4 bedroom residence, offering a piece of history in a prime urban location.

17. Johnson’s Island, Ohio: History Amidst the Waves

Located in Lake Erie’s Sandusky Bay, Johnson’s Island holds a significant place in American history. During the Civil War, it served as a prisoner-of-war camp for Confederate officers. Today, visitors can explore the Confederate cemetery, a sobering reminder of the past, and delve into history through self-guided tours. The island’s quiet wooded areas and scenic waterfront also provide a peaceful setting for reflection and nature walks, making it both a historical and tranquil destination. A 3-4 bedroom home on Johnson’s Island costs between $250,000 and $400,000, offering historical charm alongside modern comfort.

16. Harsens Island, Michigan: The Quiet Side of Lake St. Clair

At the mouth of the St. Clair River, Harsens Island offers a laid-back atmosphere perfect for those seeking a peaceful lakeside experience. Accessible by ferry, the island is a haven for boating enthusiasts, with calm waters ideal for sailing, fishing, and kayaking. Nature lovers can explore the wetlands of the St. Clair Flats, one of the largest freshwater deltas in the world, which is home to a diverse range of wildlife. Local eateries and quaint shops add to the island’s charming appeal. Homes with 3-4 bedrooms on Harsens Island are priced between $219,800 and $360,000, combining affordability with serene waterfront living.

15. French Island, Wisconsin: Riverside Living in the Upper Mississippi

Sitting adjacent to La Crosse, French Island is a tight-knit community offering the quintessential riverside lifestyle. The island is surrounded by the Mississippi River and Lake Onalaska, making it a prime spot for fishing and boating. With several marinas and waterfront parks, it’s easy to spend days exploring the waterways. The island’s neighborhoods are filled with friendly locals, and the close proximity to La Crosse means amenities and entertainment are just a short drive away. A 3-4 bedroom home on French Island typically costs between $284,900 and $399,900, providing a charming riverside escape.

14. Sabula, Iowa: Iowa’s Only Island City

Known as the “Island City,” Sabula holds the unique distinction of being Iowa’s only island town. Located on the Mississippi River, Sabula offers stunning waterfront views and a cozy small-town vibe. Visitors can relax on the sandy beach at South Sabula Lake Park or enjoy a scenic drive across the river bridges connecting to Illinois. The town’s picturesque setting and friendly community make it a delightful stop for those exploring the river’s edge. Homes in Sabula with 3-4 bedrooms range from $150,000 to $250,000, offering an affordable slice of island life.

Related: Is it worth building an in-law suite in your house to rent out?

13. Belle Isle, Michigan: Detroit’s Island Jewel

In the midst of Detroit’s urban landscape lies Belle Isle, a 982-acre island park offering a green sanctuary for city dwellers and visitors alike. The island is home to the Belle Isle Conservatory, one of the oldest conservatories in the United States, and the Belle Isle Aquarium, which houses a diverse collection of marine life. Families can explore the Dossin Great Lakes Museum or simply enjoy picnics in the expansive parklands. With walking trails, a beach, and stunning views of the Detroit skyline, Belle Isle is a cherished gem in the Motor City. A 3-4 bedroom home near Belle Isle is priced between $150,000 and $350,000, making it a convenient and scenic option in Detroit.

12. Sugar Island, Michigan: A Quiet Retreat Near Sault Ste. Marie

Accessible only by ferry, Sugar Island offers a tranquil escape just minutes from the bustling border town of Sault Ste. Marie. The island’s unspoiled natural environment is perfect for outdoor enthusiasts looking to fish, kayak, or hike amid serene surroundings. Bird watchers will delight in the abundant wildlife, including bald eagles and herons. The island’s slow pace and friendly residents make it an ideal spot to disconnect and immerse oneself in nature. Homes with 3-4 bedrooms on Sugar Island range from $150,000 to $300,000, providing a peaceful retreat at an affordable price.

11. Grosse Ile, Michigan: Suburban Oasis in the Detroit River

Grosse Ile is a picturesque island community nestled in the Detroit River, offering a suburban feel with the charm of waterfront living. The island boasts several golf courses, marinas, and nature trails that cater to active lifestyles. Waterside parks provide beautiful spots for picnics and family gatherings, while the historic East River Road offers a scenic drive lined with elegant homes. With community events and a strong local spirit, Grosse Ile is a welcoming oasis close to the city. A 3-4 bedroom home on Grosse Ile typically costs between $333,000 and $465,700, offering suburban comfort with a waterfront lifestyle.

10. Bois Blanc Island, Michigan: A Hidden Up-North Escape

For those seeking solitude, Bois Blanc Island, affectionately known as “Boblo” by locals, is a hidden gem in the Straits of Mackinac. The island’s rugged beauty is characterized by dense forests, tranquil beaches, and an absence of commercial development. With limited amenities, it’s the perfect place to disconnect and enjoy camping, hiking, or simply relaxing by the water. The island’s remote nature offers a true escape into Michigan’s wilderness. A 3-4 bedroom home on Bois Blanc Island typically costs between $200,000 and $500,000, providing secluded living with an up-north charm.

9. Middle Bass Island, Ohio: Serenity in the Heart of Lake Erie

Nestled in Lake Erie, Middle Bass Island provides a peaceful retreat away from the more crowded nearby islands. The Middle Bass Island State Park features a marina, picnic areas, and the historic Lonz Winery, which has been revitalized for visitors to explore. Boating and fishing are popular activities, and the island’s quiet roads are perfect for cycling. With its serene environment, Middle Bass Island is ideal for those looking to unwind amidst natural beauty. Homes with 3-4 bedrooms on Middle Bass Island range from $250,000 to $500,000, offering serenity in a picturesque setting.

8. Grand Island, Michigan: A Natural Haven Near Pictured Rocks

Located just off the shore of Munising, Grand Island is a haven for nature lovers and adventurers. The island is part of the Hiawatha National Forest and offers stunning cliffs, dense forests, and abundant wildlife. Explore over 40 miles of trails by foot or mountain bike, and discover hidden beaches and historical sites like the Old North Lighthouse. Its proximity to the Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore makes it a perfect addition to any Upper Peninsula adventure. A 3-4 bedroom home on Grand Island costs between $200,000 and $450,000, making it an accessible gateway to natural wonders.

7. Drummond Island, Michigan: An Off-Roading Paradise

Known as the “Gem of the Huron,” Drummond Island is a playground for outdoor enthusiasts. The island boasts one of the largest closed-loop trail systems for off-road vehicles in the country, attracting ATV and Jeep riders from all over. Kayakers can explore the Heritage Water Trail, while geology buffs will appreciate the unique alvar rock formations. With its mix of adventure and natural beauty, Drummond Island offers an unforgettable experience. A 3-4 bedroom home on Drummond Island is priced between $250,000 and $350,000, making it an adventurer’s dream destination.

6. Madeline Island, Wisconsin: Gateway to the Apostle Islands

As the largest of the Apostle Islands, Madeline Island combines cultural richness with natural splendor. The island is home to the quaint town of La Pointe, where you can explore art galleries, museums, and local shops. Big Bay State Park offers pristine beaches and trails weaving through old-growth forests. Whether you’re kayaking along the shoreline or attending a workshop at the Madeline Island School of the Arts, there’s something for everyone on this captivating island. Homes with 3-4 bedrooms on Madeline Island typically cost between $550,000 and $750,000, offering upscale living in a stunning environment.

Related: 20 of the Best Small Towns with Fascinating Firehouse Museums and Historic Fire Stations

5. Washington Island, Wisconsin: A Scandinavian Gem in Lake Michigan

Steeped in Danish heritage, Washington Island offers a unique cultural experience in the midst of Lake Michigan. Visitors can stroll through fields of purple at the Fragrant Isle Lavender Farm, one of the largest in the Midwest, or visit the historic Washington Island Stavkirke, a wooden church modeled after ancient Norwegian designs. The island’s serene beaches and welcoming community make it a peaceful getaway steeped in tradition. A 3-4 bedroom home on Washington Island costs between $250,000 and $450,000, blending cultural heritage with tranquil island living.

4. Beaver Island, Michigan: The Emerald Isle of the Great Lakes

Often referred to as America’s Emerald Isle, Beaver Island is the largest island in Lake Michigan and boasts a rich Irish history. The island’s lighthouses, like the Beaver Island Harbor Light, offer a glimpse into its maritime past. Pristine beaches, clear waters, and abundant wildlife create a tranquil environment perfect for relaxation. With festivals celebrating its heritage and plenty of outdoor activities, Beaver Island is a charming destination steeped in lore. Homes with 3-4 bedrooms on Beaver Island range from $250,000 to $550,000, making it a peaceful and historic retreat.

3. Kelleys Island, Ohio: Nature’s Paradise on Lake Erie

The largest American island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is a haven for nature enthusiasts. The island is home to the Glacial Grooves State Memorial, the largest accessible glacial grooves in the world, offering a fascinating peek into Earth’s ancient history. Hiking and biking trails traverse the island’s lush landscapes, while sandy beaches invite you to soak up the sun. The quiet village center provides quaint shops and eateries that complete this idyllic retreat. A 3-4 bedroom home on Kelleys Island costs between $250,000 and $500,000, combining natural beauty with laid-back charm.

Related: 7,580 Sq. Ft. Property in Naperville, IL ($2,499,900)

2. Put-in-Bay, Ohio: The Party Hub of Lake Erie

Known as the “Key West of the North,” Put-in-Bay on South Bass Island is famed for its vibrant nightlife and festive atmosphere. The downtown area is bustling with waterfront restaurants, lively bars, and unique shops. History buffs can visit Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial, towering over the island as a tribute to those who fought in the Battle of Lake Erie during the War of 1812. Whether you’re there for the music, boating, or social scene, Put-in-Bay promises a memorable experience. A 3-4 bedroom home in Put-in-Bay ranges from $390,000 to $610,500, blending vibrant living with lakeside charm.

1. Mackinac Island, Michigan: A Timeless Victorian Retreat

At the top of our list is the enchanting Mackinac Island, where time seems to stand still. Famous for its ban on motor vehicles, the island offers horse-drawn carriages and bicycles as the primary modes of transportation, preserving its 19th-century charm. The streets are lined with Victorian architecture, fudge shops, and boutiques. Don’t miss the historic Grand Hotel, boasting the world’s longest porch, and Fort Mackinac, which offers interactive exhibits and stunning views. With its rich history and captivating beauty, Mackinac Island is the quintessential Midwest island town. A 3-4 bedroom home on Mackinac Island is priced between $1,700,000 and $1,800,000, offering unmatched luxury in a timeless setting.