Sick of Sky-High House Prices? These 18 Wisconsin Towns Are Keeping It Real (May 2025)

According to the latest Zillow Home Value Index, not every corner of Wisconsin has caught the high-price fever. In fact, some towns are downright budget-friendly—and still full of charm. While the big cities steal the spotlight (and your savings), these 18 under-the-radar spots let you stretch your dollar without settling for boring. Whether you’re chasing peace and quiet or just want a house that doesn’t cost your soul, this list is your shortcut to smart, affordable living in 2025.

18. Richland Center – 78% Home Price Increase Since April 2010

• 2010: $99,025
• 2011: $95,937 (-$3,088, -3.12%)
• 2012: $94,899 (-$1,038, -1.08%)
• 2013: $93,662 (-$1,237, -1.30%)
• 2014: $97,223 (+$3,562, +3.80%)
• 2015: $94,226 (-$2,998, -3.08%)
• 2016: $98,206 (+$3,980, +4.22%)
• 2017: $103,831 (+$5,626, +5.73%)
• 2018: $109,344 (+$5,512, +5.31%)
• 2019: $119,814 (+$10,471, +9.58%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $136,197
• 2022: $151,428 (+$15,231, +11.18%)
• 2023: $157,955 (+$6,527, +4.31%)
• 2024: $164,567 (+$6,612, +4.19%)
• 2025: $176,209 (+$11,643, +7.07%)

Home values in Richland Center have grown by 78% since 2010, increasing steadily in recent years. The average 2025 price of $176,209 reflects strong demand for affordable homes in this scenic southwestern town.

Richland Center – Quiet Living in the Driftless Area

Nestled in the Driftless Region, Richland Center offers rolling hills, river views, and a slow-paced lifestyle. The town is known for its historic Frank Lloyd Wright-designed warehouse and a strong sense of local identity.

Affordable real estate and a peaceful setting make it attractive to first-time buyers and retirees alike. Proximity to natural attractions like Pine River and nearby state parks gives it bonus appeal for outdoor lovers.

17. Niagara – 95% Home Price Increase Since April 2010

• 2010: $89,192
• 2011: $80,609 (-$8,583, -9.62%)
• 2012: $85,632 (+$5,023, +6.23%)
• 2013: $88,763 (+$3,132, +3.66%)
• 2014: $90,382 (+$1,619, +1.82%)
• 2015: $93,690 (+$3,308, +3.66%)
• 2016: $95,549 (+$1,859, +1.98%)
• 2017: $99,803 (+$4,254, +4.45%)
• 2018: $101,594 (+$1,791, +1.79%)
• 2019: $107,895 (+$6,301, +6.20%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $129,671
• 2022: $147,123 (+$17,452, +13.46%)
• 2023: $155,144 (+$8,021, +5.45%)
• 2024: $160,292 (+$5,147, +3.32%)
• 2025: $173,608 (+$13,316, +8.31%)

Niagara’s home values have nearly doubled since 2010. A 2025 average of $173,608 places it among Wisconsin’s most affordable towns with steady appreciation.

Niagara – Border Town With Steady Growth

Positioned on the Menominee River along the Michigan border, Niagara blends small-town tranquility with outdoor access. It’s ideal for buyers seeking nature, community, and affordability.

The steady climb in home prices reflects renewed local interest and a livable cost of housing that remains attractive in a cooling market.

16. Antigo – 102% Home Price Increase Since April 2012

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: $85,886
• 2013: $94,236 (+$8,350, +9.72%)
• 2014: $94,409 (+$172, +0.18%)
• 2015: $94,306 (-$103, -0.11%)
• 2016: $96,551 (+$2,246, +2.38%)
• 2017: $97,919 (+$1,368, +1.42%)
• 2018: $102,874 (+$4,955, +5.06%)
• 2019: $111,697 (+$8,823, +8.58%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $135,694
• 2022: $148,887 (+$13,193, +9.72%)
• 2023: $152,558 (+$3,671, +2.47%)
• 2024: $163,080 (+$10,521, +6.90%)
• 2025: $173,577 (+$10,497, +6.44%)

Since 2012, home values in Antigo have increased by 102%. As of April 2025, homes average $173,577—offering affordability with reliable long-term gains.

Antigo – A Northern Hub With Stable Growth

Antigo serves as the economic and civic center of Langlade County. With schools, a small hospital, and community events, it balances small-town living with regional importance.

It has attracted steady housing interest thanks to low prices and access to parks, trails, and forests nearby. Long-term buyers appreciate the balance of value and livability.

15. Cassville – 99% Home Price Increase Since April 2012

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: $86,566
• 2013: $86,074 (-$491, -0.57%)
• 2014: $95,332 (+$9,258, +10.75%)
• 2015: $99,659 (+$4,327, +4.54%)
• 2016: $100,106 (+$447, +0.45%)
• 2017: $102,461 (+$2,355, +2.35%)
• 2018: $109,117 (+$6,656, +6.50%)
• 2019: $117,892 (+$8,775, +8.04%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $137,253
• 2022: $156,708 (+$19,455, +14.17%)
• 2023: $157,152 (+$445, +0.28%)
• 2024: $166,389 (+$9,237, +5.88%)
• 2025: $172,574 (+$6,185, +3.72%)

Cassville’s housing market has nearly doubled in value since 2012, ending at $172,574 in 2025. The town has gained popularity in recent years while still maintaining price accessibility.

Cassville – Riverside Living at a Bargain

Cassville sits along the Mississippi River in Grant County, offering scenic views, river access, and a peaceful atmosphere. The town has a rich ferry history and draws residents with its natural beauty and close-knit vibe.

Despite being somewhat remote, Cassville’s home values reflect renewed interest from buyers looking for affordable water-adjacent homes. It’s a rare opportunity to live by the river without high real estate costs.

14. Argonne – 63% Home Price Increase Since April 2012

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: $104,364
• 2013: $102,522 (-$1,842, -1.76%)
• 2014: $110,887 (+$8,365, +8.16%)
• 2015: $116,912 (+$6,025, +5.43%)
• 2016: $119,165 (+$2,253, +1.93%)
• 2017: $115,622 (-$3,543, -2.97%)
• 2018: $119,625 (+$4,003, +3.46%)
• 2019: $125,921 (+$6,296, +5.26%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $149,495
• 2022: $174,630 (+$25,136, +16.81%)
• 2023: $180,632 (+$6,002, +3.44%)
• 2024: $170,863 (-$9,769, -5.41%)
• 2025: $170,467 (-$396, -0.23%)

Argonne’s housing market has grown 63% since 2012. Prices peaked in 2023 before easing slightly, landing at $170,467 in 2025—still a strong position for a rural community in the Northwoods.

Argonne – Remote and Affordable in the Northwoods

Argonne is located in Forest County and surrounded by lush forests, lakes, and wildlife. It’s an excellent spot for hunting, fishing, and those wanting to escape urban life entirely.

Though small and remote, the area has seen increasing demand, especially from vacation-home buyers and retirees. Its recent price plateau may represent a short-term correction rather than a loss of long-term appeal.

13. Pembine – 153% Home Price Increase Since April 2010

• 2010: $65,416
• 2011: $64,639 (-$777, -1.19%)
• 2012: $66,705 (+$2,066, +3.20%)
• 2013: $69,884 (+$3,179, +4.77%)
• 2014: $71,875 (+$1,991, +2.85%)
• 2015: $76,087 (+$4,211, +5.86%)
• 2016: $78,038 (+$1,951, +2.56%)
• 2017: $78,094 (+$56, +0.07%)
• 2018: $84,130 (+$6,036, +7.73%)
• 2019: $90,772 (+$6,642, +7.89%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $110,066
• 2022: $130,525 (+$20,459, +18.59%)
• 2023: $141,897 (+$11,371, +8.71%)
• 2024: $149,739 (+$7,842, +5.53%)
• 2025: $165,786 (+$16,047, +10.71%)

Pembine’s home values have surged 153% since 2010, finishing at $165,786 in 2025. It’s one of the fastest-appreciating towns in this roundup while still being affordable by statewide standards.

Pembine – Affordable Entry to the Northwoods

Located in Marinette County near the Michigan border, Pembine offers forests, rivers, and trail systems in every direction. It’s popular with outdoorsy homebuyers and vacationers alike.

Despite consistent gains, prices remain below $170K, making Pembine a rare blend of value and lifestyle potential. Steady appreciation shows it’s on more buyers’ radar without overheating.

12. Armstrong Creek – 49% Home Price Increase Since April 2015

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: $110,449
• 2017: $114,005 (+$3,557, +3.22%)
• 2018: $119,098 (+$5,093, +4.47%)
• 2019: $122,420 (+$3,322, +2.79%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $144,624
• 2022: $168,141 (+$23,517, +16.25%)
• 2023: $173,068 (+$4,927, +2.93%)
• 2024: $166,469 (-$6,599, -3.81%)
• 2025: $164,462 (-$2,007, -1.21%)

Armstrong Creek has seen a 49% increase in average home values since 2015, with most of the growth occurring between 2021 and 2023. Although prices dipped slightly in 2024 and 2025, the market remains well above its mid-2010s baseline, with a 2025 average of $164,462.

Armstrong Creek – Rustic Appeal With Measured Growth

Located in the heart of Forest County, Armstrong Creek is a tiny town surrounded by lakes, woods, and serenity. With a population under 500, it’s a haven for those wanting complete quiet and outdoor access, especially hunters, anglers, and snowmobilers. The area is surrounded by Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest land.

Home prices here reflect seasonal interest rather than constant market pressure. Growth has been strong in recent years, likely driven by increased demand for vacation properties and remote retreats. With home values now topping $164,000, Armstrong Creek still delivers peace and privacy at a cost far below the state’s urban centers.

11. Clintonville – 152% Home Price Increase Since April 2010

• 2010: $64,811
• 2011: $63,250 (-$1,561, -2.41%)
• 2012: $62,708 (-$542, -0.86%)
• 2013: $65,031 (+$2,323, +3.70%)
• 2014: $65,112 (+$81, +0.12%)
• 2015: $70,487 (+$5,375, +8.26%)
• 2016: $70,510 (+$23, +0.03%)
• 2017: $76,260 (+$5,750, +8.15%)
• 2018: $84,733 (+$8,473, +11.11%)
• 2019: $91,768 (+$7,035, +8.30%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $108,580
• 2022: $118,934 (+$10,354, +9.54%)
• 2023: $128,470 (+$9,536, +8.02%)
• 2024: $149,021 (+$20,552, +15.99%)
• 2025: $163,255 (+$14,234, +9.55%)

Clintonville’s housing market has surged more than 150% since 2010, a dramatic increase for a town of its size. Prices have risen steadily each year, with the average home now costing $163,255—still significantly more affordable than the state median.

Clintonville – Strong Gains in a Classic Wisconsin Town

Located in Waupaca County, Clintonville is a classic small town with a proud industrial and agricultural history. It’s the birthplace of four-wheel-drive technology and remains an important local hub for schools, services, and manufacturing. The community retains a close-knit feel with solid infrastructure and modest amenities.

The sharp uptick in home values points to increased demand, likely from both locals and newcomers recognizing the town’s quality of life. Clintonville’s well-maintained homes, parks, and walkable downtown make it a stable, desirable place to settle for those priced out of larger markets.

10. Lohrville – 67% Home Price Increase Since April 2016

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: N/A
• 2017: $91,087
• 2018: $100,812 (+$9,725, +10.67%)
• 2019: $104,555 (+$3,743, +3.71%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $121,115
• 2022: $128,289 (+$7,174, +5.92%)
• 2023: $130,781 (+$2,492, +1.94%)
• 2024: $145,636 (+$14,855, +11.36%)
• 2025: $152,477 (+$6,842, +4.70%)

Since 2016, Lohrville has seen a steady 67% increase in average home values. The pace has quickened recently, with double-digit gains in 2024 followed by a smaller bump in 2025. At $152,477, the town remains affordable and on an upward trend.

Lohrville – Quiet Village With Room to Grow

Lohrville, located in Waushara County, is a compact village near Wautoma that quietly delivers value. It’s close to outdoor attractions like Silver Lake and the Ice Age Trail, offering both nature and convenience in one low-key package. The village has a population under 500, making it ideal for those seeking tranquility and privacy.

The town’s upward price trend is a good sign of health, not hype. Homes here are often older and modest, but the stability in growth suggests local interest is strong. Buyers seeking quiet surroundings with potential upside may want to keep Lohrville on their radar.

9. Tigerton – 104% Home Price Increase Since April 2016

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: N/A
• 2017: $73,102
• 2018: $79,132 (+$6,030, +8.25%)
• 2019: $85,061 (+$5,929, +7.49%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $102,957
• 2022: $106,388 (+$3,431, +3.33%)
• 2023: $108,258 (+$1,870, +1.76%)
• 2024: $139,273 (+$31,015, +28.64%)
• 2025: $148,967 (+$9,694, +6.96%)

Since 2016, Tigerton’s housing market has surged by over 100%. The most significant jump occurred between 2023 and 2024, when values leapt nearly 29%. The town closed 2025 with an average home price of $148,967, making it a strong candidate for buyers interested in rural value with serious growth potential.

Tigerton – A Quiet Village on a Rapid Rise

Located in Shawano County, Tigerton is a small community surrounded by farmland, forests, and the Embarrass River. Its peaceful streets and historic architecture reflect its logging and milling roots, but recent years have seen a subtle transformation. Affordable land, open space, and natural surroundings have begun to attract both locals and outsiders looking for an escape from busier urban life.

In recent years, housing demand in Tigerton has increased thanks to broader interest in remote living and low property taxes. There’s a growing appeal for those seeking a base for homesteading, outdoor recreation, or simply a quieter pace of life. Though development remains minimal, the spike in price growth shows that this village is no longer off the radar. Tigerton may be small, but its trajectory shows momentum and long-term promise.

8. Goodman – 41% Home Price Increase Since April 2018

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: N/A
• 2016: N/A
• 2017: N/A
• 2018: N/A
• 2019: N/A
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $105,193
• 2022: $123,006 (+$17,812, +16.93%)
• 2023: $133,706 (+$10,700, +8.70%)
• 2024: $132,210 (-$1,496, -1.12%)
• 2025: $148,437 (+$16,227, +12.28%)

Home values in Goodman rose 41% from 2018 to 2022, peaking just under $150,000. The strongest gains came between 2018 and 2020, followed by a slight dip and another jump in 2022. Even without full 2025 data, Goodman’s housing market shows strong long-term potential at prices still within reach for most buyers.

Goodman – Deep in the Northwoods, High on Value

Goodman is a small town in Marinette County nestled within the vast northern forests of Wisconsin. With its location deep in the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest, the area attracts hunters, campers, and seasonal residents looking for a rustic and remote experience. Its charm lies not in commercial development, but in the lakes, rivers, and wooded acreage that define daily life here.

Though small, Goodman has seen a noticeable increase in buyer attention over the last several years. As remote work becomes more accepted and the cost of living in cities rises, towns like Goodman offer an affordable and peaceful alternative. The local economy remains modest, but stable—rooted in timber, tourism, and outdoor recreation. For those seeking cabin-country living, second homes, or retirement properties with room to breathe, Goodman is an appealing contender that’s still priced to move.

7. Long Lake – 71% Home Price Increase Since April 2013

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: $86,627
• 2015: $86,555 (-$72, -0.08%)
• 2016: $89,107 (+$2,552, +2.95%)
• 2017: $91,853 (+$2,746, +3.08%)
• 2018: $97,839 (+$5,986, +6.52%)
• 2019: $105,527 (+$7,688, +7.86%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $124,354
• 2022: $144,946 (+$20,592, +16.56%)
• 2023: $146,536 (+$1,590, +1.10%)
• 2024: $146,393 (-$143, -0.10%)
• 2025: $148,143 (+$1,750, +1.20%)

Since 2013, Long Lake’s housing values have increased 71%, with consistent year-over-year growth. While 2024 and 2025 saw small shifts, prices remained stable, ending at an affordable $148,143 in 2025. The long-term gains highlight a market that is growing steadily, not speculatively.

Long Lake – Quiet Lake Life Without the Premium

Long Lake is located in Florence County, a remote region of Wisconsin that borders the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. The town is surrounded by—true to its name—dozens of lakes and forest preserves, making it a magnet for fishing, kayaking, and snowmobiling. What sets Long Lake apart from better-known resort areas is its affordability. Here, you can enjoy waterfront access and secluded cabins without competing with high-dollar vacation crowds.

Its location keeps demand modest, but increasingly consistent. The post-2020 shift toward lifestyle-driven home buying has brought more eyes to places like Long Lake. As retirees, remote workers, and seasonal buyers search for natural beauty at a lower cost, Long Lake has emerged as a quietly rising market. It offers one of the best cost-to-scenery ratios in the state for those willing to live off the beaten path.

6. Glidden – 42% Home Price Increase Since April 2012

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: $104,201
• 2013: $105,961 (+$1,760, +1.69%)
• 2014: $100,756 (-$5,205, -4.91%)
• 2015: $100,322 (-$434, -0.43%)
• 2016: $104,193 (+$3,871, +3.86%)
• 2017: $105,037 (+$844, +0.81%)
• 2018: $108,850 (+$3,813, +3.63%)
• 2019: $112,895 (+$4,045, +3.72%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $135,740
• 2022: $154,181 (+$18,441, +13.58%)
• 2023: $160,555 (+$6,374, +4.14%)
• 2024: $164,020 (+$3,465, +2.16%)
• 2025: $148,094 (-$15,926, -9.71%)

Glidden’s home prices are up 42% since 2012, with a mix of small year-over-year changes and one notable drop in 2025. Despite that correction, home values remain higher than they were even two years ago. Its 2025 average of $148,094 reflects affordable rural housing with modest long-term gains.

Glidden – Forest Access, Historic Roots, and Room to Breathe

Glidden is a small unincorporated community in Ashland County, known as the “Black Bear Capital of Wisconsin.” Its location inside the Chequamegon National Forest makes it a top destination for hunters, snowmobilers, and anyone who wants direct access to wilderness. It’s not a place for big-box convenience—but for some, that’s exactly the point.

The town has experienced slow, steady housing growth with only a few price surges. The dip in 2025 may be a reflection of limited inventory or market cooling after strong growth in 2022 and 2023. Still, for those looking to settle where nature dominates and neighbors are few, Glidden offers both lifestyle and affordability. It’s the kind of place where “quiet” isn’t just a selling point—it’s a way of life.

5. Hawkins – 69% Home Price Increase Since April 2016

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: N/A
• 2017: $87,199
• 2018: $90,339 (+$3,140, +3.60%)
• 2019: $96,937 (+$6,598, +7.30%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $123,438
• 2022: $148,001 (+$24,563, +19.90%)
• 2023: $148,490 (+$489, +0.33%)
• 2024: $142,630 (-$5,860, -3.95%)
• 2025: $147,776 (+$5,146, +3.61%)

Hawkins has seen a 69% increase in home prices since 2016, led by a large jump in 2022. Though prices dipped slightly in 2024, they recovered quickly by 2025, ending at $147,776. The town’s affordability and rural charm continue to support steady market interest.

Hawkins – Northern Seclusion With a Strong Price Surge

Located in Rusk County, Hawkins is a quiet village nestled between the Flambeau River State Forest and thousands of acres of public lands. It has long attracted hunters, trappers, and those in search of off-grid solitude. With just a few hundred residents, this is a place where community feels personal and the nearest Walmart is over 30 miles away.

Hawkins saw a sudden leap in home prices in 2022, likely fueled by demand from urban buyers looking for more space and fewer neighbors. While it cooled slightly the following year, the market recovered quickly, showing underlying resilience. If you’re seeking privacy, proximity to wilderness, and a lifestyle that’s entirely unplugged, Hawkins continues to deliver it—without the hefty price tag.

4. Mellen – 36% Home Price Increase Since April 2022

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: N/A
• 2016: N/A
• 2017: N/A
• 2018: N/A
• 2019: N/A
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: N/A
• 2022: N/A
• 2023: N/A
• 2024: $151,064
• 2025: $143,179 (-$7,885, -5.22%)

Mellen’s home values rose rapidly in 2022, then settled back slightly in the following years. Despite a 5% drop by 2025, prices remain up 36% over the span of tracked data. Its current average of $143,179 makes it one of the most affordable towns in northern Wisconsin with recent upward movement.

Mellen – Scenic Gateway to Copper Falls

Mellen is a small town in Ashland County best known as the gateway to Copper Falls State Park—one of the most beautiful natural attractions in Wisconsin. The town itself is quiet and compact, featuring historic buildings, a central school, and a population of around 700 residents. It’s a town where everything feels local, from the hardware store to the public library.

The local housing market appears to have peaked in 2022 but remains far above previous years. For nature lovers, Mellen offers instant access to waterfalls, hiking, and wooded acreage, while still delivering small-town affordability. It’s a strong choice for anyone seeking value in a community that feels rooted and authentic.

3. Bagley – 59% Home Price Increase Since April 2015

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: $84,264
• 2017: $87,726 (+$3,462, +4.11%)
• 2018: $91,390 (+$3,664, +4.18%)
• 2019: $98,669 (+$7,279, +7.97%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $108,610
• 2022: $118,782 (+$10,172, +9.37%)
• 2023: $129,786 (+$11,004, +9.26%)
• 2024: $131,073 (+$1,287, +0.99%)
• 2025: $134,758 (+$3,685, +2.81%)

Bagley’s housing market has grown by nearly 60% since 2015, with consistent yearly increases and a 2025 average price of $134,758. The town has seen strong and stable appreciation while remaining highly affordable by statewide standards.

Bagley – Riverfront Peace With Long-Term Value

Bagley is perched above the Mississippi River in Grant County, offering panoramic bluff views, riverside recreation, and tranquil living. Despite its picturesque setting, it has remained under the radar, keeping home prices low even as demand slowly ticks upward. Residents enjoy access to boating, camping, and beautiful drives along the Great River Road.

The real estate market here is driven by a mix of permanent residents and vacation homeowners. Its housing stock consists of modest homes and cabins, many with generous land parcels and water views. As more people seek out Wisconsin’s western border for lifestyle and scenery, Bagley is quietly becoming one of the smartest places to invest for affordability, charm, and access to nature.

2. Hurley – 57% Home Price Increase Since April 2010

• 2010: $81,706
• 2011: $80,521 (-$1,185, -1.45%)
• 2012: $77,551 (-$2,970, -3.69%)
• 2013: $79,351 (+$1,800, +2.32%)
• 2014: $82,200 (+$2,849, +3.59%)
• 2015: $84,086 (+$1,886, +2.29%)
• 2016: $85,258 (+$1,172, +1.39%)
• 2017: $91,442 (+$6,184, +7.25%)
• 2018: $94,090 (+$2,648, +2.90%)
• 2019: $101,248 (+$7,158, +7.61%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $120,480
• 2022: $132,183 (+$11,703, +9.72%)
• 2023: $138,542 (+$6,359, +4.81%)
• 2024: $131,555 (-$6,987, -5.04%)
• 2025: $127,970 (-$3,585, -2.72%)

Hurley’s home prices have increased by 57% since 2010. The market peaked in 2023 and has dipped slightly since, ending 2025 with an average price of $127,970. Despite the pullback, Hurley remains one of the most affordable towns on this list and shows solid long-term appreciation.

Hurley – Affordable Access to Adventure in Iron County

Hurley lies at the northern edge of Iron County, just across the border from Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. Known for its mining past and strong snowmobiling culture, it’s a winter paradise with hundreds of miles of trails and easy access to ski areas like Whitecap Mountains. The town is lively in the cold months but retains a close-knit, peaceful feel year-round.

Its real estate market is built around affordability, with modest homes, duplexes, and older properties that appeal to both investors and first-time buyers. While recent dips in pricing suggest some short-term correction, the long-term price curve shows healthy demand for a town that still offers a lot of bang for the buck. Hurley’s rugged charm and access to outdoor recreation make it a serious option for value seekers.

1. Montreal – 30% Home Price Increase Since April 2015

• 2010: N/A
• 2011: N/A
• 2012: N/A
• 2013: N/A
• 2014: N/A
• 2015: N/A
• 2016: $94,510
• 2017: $101,638 (+$7,128, +7.54%)
• 2018: $105,001 (+$3,363, +3.31%)
• 2019: $108,887 (+$3,886, +3.70%)
• 2020: N/A
• 2021: $123,362
• 2022: $133,449 (+$10,087, +8.18%)
• 2023: $140,154 (+$6,705, +5.02%)
• 2024: $125,147 (-$15,007, -10.71%)
• 2025: $122,577 (-$2,570, -2.05%)

Montreal has seen home values rise by 30% since 2015. Prices peaked in 2023 before dropping slightly in the past two years. Its 2025 average home price of $122,577 makes it the most affordable town in Wisconsin right now, despite years of growth.

Montreal – The Most Affordable Town in Wisconsin (2025)

Located in Iron County just south of Hurley, Montreal is a former mining town with a unique history. It was originally developed as one of the country’s first planned company towns, and many of its early-20th-century homes are still in use today. The community is compact, historic, and rooted in a tradition of hard work and resilience.

Montreal offers quick access to outdoor adventures—skiing, hiking, and ATV trails—and is just minutes from Lake Superior and the Porcupine Mountains. Its recent home price softening makes it a buyer’s market, and with average prices under $125,000, it’s a standout choice for anyone looking to stretch their housing budget without sacrificing quality of life.