Would you like to save this?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
Bathrooms have the power to make or break a home’s appeal, and buyers notice every little detail. While a stylish, functional bathroom can elevate your property’s value, the wrong choices can quietly chip away at it without you even realizing. From outdated finishes and awkward layouts to safety hazards and style fads gone wrong, certain design decisions make buyers cringe.
The truth is, people want bathrooms that feel fresh, clean, and timeless, not ones that scream “DIY disaster” or “stuck in the 90s.” To help you avoid costly mistakes, here are 34 bathroom choices that experts agree can send your home’s value spiraling downward.
34. Open-Concept Bathroom Inside Bedroom
Designers may pitch open bathrooms as “luxury,” but most buyers simply see a giant privacy nightmare. Bathrooms without walls or doors blur the line between restful retreat and functional necessity, leaving many people uncomfortable.
While it might feel trendy in a boutique hotel, it quickly loses appeal in day-to-day living when someone wants to sleep while the other showers. What seems like a bold design statement often translates to an immediate resale red flag.
33. Low-Mounted Rain Shower Without Handheld
A rain shower fixed too low turns what should be a spa-like experience into an awkward one. Buyers expect comfort, not a showerhead that soaks their shoulders instead of their head.
Without a handheld attachment, cleaning the shower or rinsing off kids and pets becomes a hassle. Poor placement and missing functionality send the message that the bathroom was more about looks than livability.
32. Zero Outlets or Poor Outlet Placement
Bathrooms need outlets in smart, convenient places, and failing to provide them is a buyer deal-breaker. Imagine trying to plug in a hairdryer across the room or worse, not having an outlet at all. Buyers don’t see this as a small oversight—they see it as bad planning and a renovation headache. It instantly raises concerns about outdated wiring and functionality that just doesn’t measure up.
31. Windowless Bath With No Daylight
Were You Meant
to Live In?
Bathrooms without natural light feel closed-in and cave-like, which instantly turns buyers off. A lack of windows or skylights creates ventilation challenges, which often lead to mildew and lingering odors. Daylight is one of the cheapest ways to make a bathroom feel larger, fresher, and more inviting. Without it, the space feels gloomy and artificial, diminishing its appeal and value.
30. Removing Linen Closet For Minimalism
Storage is one of the most underrated assets in any bathroom, and eliminating it for the sake of “minimalist design” rarely pays off. Buyers quickly notice when there’s nowhere to stash towels, toiletries, or cleaning supplies. A sleek look means little when everyday function is sacrificed. In fact, the lack of storage makes clutter inevitable—defeating the minimalist goal entirely.
29. No Waterproofing Behind Shower Tile
Cutting corners on waterproofing might save money during a remodel, but it’s a hidden disaster waiting to happen. Without a proper membrane, water seeps into walls and floors, causing mold and costly structural damage. Savvy buyers know to ask about what’s behind the tile, and inspectors catch these shortcuts quickly. Nothing tanks a home’s worth faster than the threat of water damage.
28. Clawfoot Tub Without Proper Shower
While clawfoot tubs can be charming, they lose their appeal if they’re the only bathing option. Without a proper shower setup, daily use becomes inconvenient for most buyers. People want charm, but they also want practicality, and climbing into a freestanding tub every day isn’t realistic. What feels romantic in theory often translates into an impractical eyesore at resale.
27. Barn Door Instead of Privacy Door
Barn doors may look trendy in living rooms, but they’re terrible choices for bathrooms. They never fully seal, leaving gaps that compromise both sound and privacy—two things people value highly in bathrooms. Buyers immediately picture awkward scenarios with houseguests or family members. While they might be stylish, they send a clear message that form was valued over function.
26. Matte-Black Everything Without Contrast
All-black bathrooms photograph well on Instagram, but in real life they often feel harsh and oppressive. Without balance or contrast, the look can quickly turn from chic to claustrophobic. Buyers worry about the upkeep of fingerprints and soap scum that show on every surface. Instead of feeling modern, the space often ends up feeling dark and unwelcoming.
25. Cheap Plastic Chrome Fixtures
Plastic fixtures with chrome plating scream “budget remodel” and wear out quickly. Buyers can spot flimsy materials the second they touch them, and they immediately assume other corners were cut. While metal fixtures cost more upfront, they hold up longer and feel far more substantial. Going cheap here makes an entire bathroom renovation feel less trustworthy.
24. Overmount Sinks With Grimy Rims
Drop-in sinks with raised rims trap grime and make cleaning a chore, which buyers dislike instantly. They’re considered outdated compared to seamless undermount or integrated sinks. The exposed edges collect soap scum and water stains that are hard to keep fresh-looking. It’s a small detail that signals an old, less functional bathroom design.
23. Fake-Stone Peel-and-Stick Panels
Peel-and-stick “stone” panels may seem like an easy upgrade, but most buyers see them as cheap and fake. They rarely hold up well in a damp environment like a bathroom, peeling at the edges and trapping moisture. Instead of adding charm, they cheapen the overall look. Buyers expect real finishes, not quick DIY disguises.
22. Ornate Tuscan-Style Cabinetry
Heavy, dark cabinetry with carved details screams early-2000s luxury, and not in a good way. Today’s buyers are looking for clean lines, light tones, and a sense of openness. Overly ornate vanities feel bulky and eat up visual space, making bathrooms look smaller. What once felt “high-end” now comes across as dated and overwhelming.
21. Over-the-Top Themed Tile Murals
Tile murals of dolphins, palm trees, or Grecian goddesses may reflect personality, but they almost always hurt resale. Buyers don’t want to inherit someone else’s quirky theme in such a permanent form. These murals dominate the space and limit future design options. What feels like art to one person is a costly eyesore to another.
20. Mismatched Metal Finishes Everywhere
A little mixing of finishes can look intentional, but a chaotic blend of chrome, brass, and bronze just looks messy. Buyers read it as a lack of design vision or worse, a patchwork of budget updates over time. Bathrooms need cohesion to feel polished. Too many finishes create visual clutter that distracts from the space’s functionality.
19. Glass-Block Privacy Windows
Glass-block windows once promised light and privacy, but now they’re seen as clunky relics of the past. Their bulky, grid-like appearance dates the space instantly. Modern buyers prefer frosted glass or sleek window treatments that provide the same benefits without the outdated look. Glass blocks signal a bathroom that hasn’t been touched in decades.
18. Brass-and-Glass 1990s Shower Enclosure
Nothing dates a bathroom faster than a brass-framed shower enclosure with frosted glass. It instantly transports buyers back to a design era that has long since expired. The metal tarnishes quickly and the style feels bulky compared to today’s frameless glass options. Most buyers will mentally factor in replacement costs the moment they see it.
17. Toilet As The Focal Point
Walking into a bathroom and seeing the toilet front and center is never a selling point. Buyers prefer layouts where the toilet is tucked discreetly out of immediate view. A poorly placed toilet makes the bathroom feel awkward and less refined. While it may not seem like a big deal, it leaves a lasting negative impression on buyers.
16. Open Shelving Beside Toilet
Would you like to save this?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
While open shelving can look chic elsewhere, next to a toilet it just feels unhygienic. Buyers imagine dust, moisture, and worse collecting on those exposed surfaces. The lack of privacy for stored items also makes the bathroom look cluttered. Instead of stylish, the choice reads as impractical and unappealing.
15. Pedestal Sink In Family Bath
Pedestal sinks might work in powder rooms, but in a full bathroom they’re a storage nightmare. Families need space for toiletries, cleaning supplies, and other essentials. Without cabinetry, the bathroom feels incomplete and less functional. Buyers want vanities that combine style with storage, not elegant inconvenience.
14. High-Gloss Slippery Floor Tile
Glossy tiles may look sleek, but in a bathroom they pose a dangerous slip risk. Buyers with kids or elderly family members see them as safety hazards. The constant upkeep to keep them streak-free and polished also adds to the headache. A shiny floor quickly shifts from glamorous to impractical in a buyer’s eyes.
13. Tiny Tile With Thick Grout
Small mosaic tiles might sound charming until buyers think about cleaning all that grout. Thick grout lines trap dirt, mold, and discoloration faster than larger tiles. The bathroom ends up looking dingy despite regular scrubbing. Buyers see this as high maintenance, which is never a selling point.
12. Busy Mosaic Tile Overload
A little mosaic detail can be stunning, but covering entire walls or floors overwhelms the space. Buyers want calm and clean bathrooms, not dizzying patterns that dominate. Too much mosaic makes the bathroom feel chaotic and quickly goes out of style. Resale-wise, it reads as a dated design indulgence.
11. Dark, Cave-Like Paint Colors
Deep, moody colors can work in a bedroom, but in a bathroom they make the space feel small and oppressive. Buyers associate dark bathrooms with poor lighting and lack of cleanliness. Bathrooms should feel open and fresh, not like a dungeon. The wrong paint color alone can sink an otherwise solid remodel.
10. No Ventilation Fan Or Window
Lack of ventilation is a major buyer red flag because it leads to mold, mildew, and lingering odors. A bathroom without a fan or window feels poorly designed and unhealthy. Buyers know they’ll have to invest in fixes immediately. What looks like a simple oversight actually signals a costly problem.
9. Shower Curtain Instead Of Glass
Shower curtains are cheap and functional, but they instantly downgrade a bathroom’s look. Buyers prefer glass enclosures that feel sleek, modern, and easier to clean. Curtains also feel temporary and less sanitary, often harboring mildew. They make even updated bathrooms feel unfinished and outdated.
8. Oversized Corner Whirlpool Tub
Corner whirlpool tubs take up massive amounts of floor space while rarely being used. Buyers see them as relics of the 1990s that eat into valuable square footage. They’re expensive to maintain and look bulky compared to modern freestanding tubs. Most buyers would rather have a roomy shower than a giant tub collecting dust.
7. Eliminating The Home’s Only Bathtub
Getting rid of the only tub in a home may seem practical, but it hurts resale value. Families with young kids and buyers who enjoy soaking see it as a major loss. Even if you personally prefer showers, future owners may not. Without at least one tub, your home appeals to a much smaller pool of buyers.
6. Vessel Sinks That Splash
Vessel sinks look dramatic on Pinterest but frustrate buyers in real life. They tend to splash water everywhere and can feel awkward for everyday use. Cleaning around and inside them is also more tedious. What looks chic in photos often feels like a high-maintenance gimmick in practice.
5. Hollywood Strip Vanity Lights
The row of big round bulbs above the mirror might scream “movie star,” but to buyers it screams “dated.” They cast harsh, unflattering light and make a bathroom feel stuck in the 1980s. Modern lighting is all about balance and softness. These glaring fixtures immediately signal the need for an upgrade.
4. Builder-Grade Unframed Vanity Mirror
Plain slab mirrors without frames or detail are a telltale sign of a basic, uninspired bathroom. They don’t add character or style and make the space feel bland. Buyers today expect at least some design effort, even in small details. Something as simple as a framed mirror adds instant polish and appeal.
3. Plastic Laminate Countertops
Laminate counters in a bathroom are a cost-saving shortcut that buyers notice immediately. They scratch, warp, and discolor far faster than stone or quartz. While they may have been standard decades ago, today they just look cheap. For buyers, they’re a clear sign the bathroom needs a full remodel.
2. Peel-and-Stick Floor Tiles
Stick-on floor tiles scream temporary fix instead of real renovation. They peel, bubble, and discolor easily in damp bathroom conditions. Buyers see them as a red flag for low-quality upgrades. Rather than enhancing value, they undermine the entire space’s credibility.
1. Carpeted Bathroom Floors
Carpet in bathrooms tops the list because it’s universally disliked by buyers. It traps moisture, harbors odors, and quickly becomes unsanitary. Even if it’s freshly installed, buyers see it as an immediate replacement project. Nothing says “outdated and unhygienic” faster than stepping onto bathroom carpet.
Haven't Seen Yet
Curated from our most popular plans. Click any to explore.
Would you like to save this?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
