Skip to Content

Are Brushless Tools Better?

Photo collage of different Brushless Tools.

Brushless tools are better than brushed ones as they need less upkeep, have better efficiency, plus less noise and heat. Using one or several permanent magnets, brushless motors are synchronized devices. Brushless motor power devices have recently become a premium option, including grinders, hedge trimmers, jackhammers, and drills.

ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Cordless 4-Tool Combo Kit with 4.0 Ah Battery, 2.0 Ah Battery, Charger, and Bag

The rotor plus stator are the two electrical components that make up a DC motor. When applied to the motor, it produces a magnetic reaction that drives the motor into action. Changing the polarity of the energy that drives the motor causes it to spin in the other direction.

It’s general knowledge that brushless, as well as brushed motors, are the two most popular varieties. They have the same underlying basic principles, but their form, function, and control are very different. Let’s look further at what differentiates brushed and brushless tools and which are the ruthless Tools Better.

Based on countless reviews and interviews with construction experts, while both tools have their pros and cons, brushless benefits outweigh that of brushed tools. That includes the way both types of tools generate power.

2526-20 M12 Brushless 12-Volt Lithium-Ion Cordless Oscillating Multi-Tool (Tool-Only)

The rise of the brushless motor, which began in the 1960s, culminated in its widespread use in the ’80s. This kind of motor can provide as much force as brushed ones thanks to the increased accessibility of permanent magnets and high-voltage transistors. Over the past three decades, advancements in the brushless versions have not slowed.

Drill makers may now make more effective tools thanks to this advancement. As a result, buyers are capitalizing on the advantages of diversity and low maintenance costs.

Brushless vs Brushed Tools

Vbestlife Brushed Motor,MY6812 12V 120W DC Brush High Speed Motor for Electric Scooter

In contrast to brushless drill motors, which employ magnets to generate power, brushed models are constructed of carbon. Thus, brushless motors are more versatile, cause no friction, generate less heat, and deliver superior performance. Also, since we don’t have to replace worn brushes, brushless devices require hardly any upkeep other than the occasional dusting.

The windings in a brushless tool are commutated not mechanically, but electronically, by a controller. To generate the rotating field, the DC is inverted into a three-phase, variable-frequency current and supplied to the motor coils in sequence. It makes sense that, unlike brushed motors, the coils in a DC motor do not revolve freely.

Despite their differences, all brushless motors share a common structure. They feature a stationary “stator” that stores the coils and a “rotor” that can be moved about and adheres to the permanent magnets. They can construct the windings in a variety of shapes, including a star and a triangle.

Most brushless feature an internal rotor that may reach speeds of up to 100,000 revolutions per minute.

Understanding What the Brushes in Tools Are

12V Max Brushed Powerful Cordless Impact Screwdriver Drill with Battery 1/4 in

Brushes are critical to the operation of brushed motor power tools. Carbon brushes are selected for use with specific power tools based on brand and function. Placed on the stationary portion of a motor, they facilitate the efficient transfer of energy to the rotating section.

They allow switching to occur without the use of a spark. These parts, which usually come in pairs, are frictional and wear with time. There is always friction between the carbon brushes and the slip rings.

These parts, which are made of graphite, can be found in a variety of styles. The brush holder may or may not include a spring, connector (wire with plug), or both. The brushes can be found in a variety of sizes and forms (most commonly square and rectangular) and some even feature grooves to aid in navigation.

The magnetic field strength is taken into account while determining the drill’s speed, which is expressed as torque. Power is transmitted without interruption thanks to carbon brushes mounted on a spring and fitted with a plate. The brushes may also be attached to a spring-loaded brush holder that provides additional propulsion.

However, breaker brushes are employed to interrupt motor and drill operations before the graphite material wears out completely. The goal is to keep everything functioning at its best. Brushes that work with many brands of drills can be purchased from the tool’s manufacturer.

The height, width, and depth are all given in millimeters or inches. These specs may change from manufacturer to manufacturer, though.

Restrictions of Brushed Tools

Despite their many benefits, such as low cost, great reliability, and a high inertia ratio or torque, brushed motors nevertheless have a few drawbacks. As time passes, dust accumulates on these worn parts. The brushes in an electric motor like this one need to be cleaned or replaced regularly.

Additionally, they are prone to arcing on the brushes, which causes electromagnetic interference (EMI), poor top speed, plus limited ability to dissipate heat. Similar to brushed motors, brushless motors use a switching control based on feedback from the internal position of the shaft, but their physical construction is different. Brushless units are more efficient because they are designed to disperse heat from the stator coils and have lower internal resistance.

Therefore, the efficiency is higher because the heat of the coils can be dissipated more efficiently by the considerably bigger stationary motor casing. The brushless motor’s permanent magnet is on the rotor, as opposed to the stator in a brushed motor. The coil windings reside in the stator, which is made of grooved rolled steel.

However, the brushed units perform admirably in constrained environments because they need so few external components.

What are Brushless Drill Motors?

Understanding brushless requires looking at the fundamental structure of these motors. You can group stator windings in either a delta or star form. Grooves are optional while rolling steel.

The inductance of a drill motor is decreased when the windings are smooth. That means it can function more quickly while generating fewer ripples at reduced speeds. The need to increase the number of windings to account for the additional airspace is its primary drawback.

Depending on the use, the ideal rotor pole quantity might be different. While adding more poles boosts torque, it also decreases top speed. The maximal torque rises with the flux density, but this is also affected by the material used to produce the permanent magnets.

Controlling a brushless motor is more complicated than the control of a brushed motor since the switching happens electronically. Control is exercised in both a digital and analog way. Though the fundamental control block is analogous to that used with brushed motors, closed-loop control is required here.

Brushless Tools Algorithms

Brushless motors have three common control algorithms: vector, sinusoidal commutation, and trapezoidal commutation. It is up to the programmer and the hardware designer to decide how to implement each distinct control algorithm. There are benefits and drawbacks to each option.

Since trapezoidal switching may be implemented with minimal hardware and software, it is a good option for prototyping and other simple uses. Six stages are involved in this procedure, all of which are based on the feedback from the rotor’s position. While trapezoidal switching is highly efficient at regulating motor speed and power, torque ripple is a problem, especially at low switching rates.

Impressive performance can be had at the expense of increased algorithm complexity by using sensorless switching. This sensorless switching minimizes component and installation costs as well as streamlines system design by doing away with Hall effect sensors plus the interface circuits.

A Brushless Motor’s Benefits

Brushless motor technology boosts the performance and durability of your cordless power tools. When using these motors, you won’t have to worry about repairs or upkeep. Brushless technology has a wide range of benefits.

When brushes aren’t involved, overheating and failures aren’t an issue. So, the bearings are the sole real factor in determining how long a brushless motor will last. In comparison to brushed motors, brushless motors are smaller in size and lighter in weight by a factor of two to three.

Reduced vibration and noise are bonuses to this already convenient improvement in portability. In today’s world of electronic commutations, pinpoint accuracy in locating is now possible. With perfectly balanced rotors, the motor can reach speeds of up to 50,000 rpm.

The electronic module allows for greater customization, a larger range of adjustment, and, most importantly, the preservation of torque right from the get-go. Efficiency increases dramatically when there is no resistance between the rotor and the stator. The battery’s potential is maximized by minimizing heat and friction.

With regular cells, this boosts performance and runtime by up to 25%. Manufacturers claim that the latest types of Li-Ion batteries offer an increase in the autonomy of up to 50%, and in some cases 60%. Without any sort of friction, the motor may run without ever sparking, no matter how hard you push it.

The lack of a contact zone in brushless technology drastically decreases wear and the need for servicing. You’ll find that the best cordless drill runs on a brushless motor, which provides several benefits, including the motor’s increased efficiency, protection against overheating, and freedom from the need for replacement brushes.

Why Do Brushless Motors Cost More Than Traditional Ones?

Brushless motor electric drone close-up.

The rotor is typically driven by the stator from within the motor. The collector or commutator makes electrical contact with tiny carbon brushes, completing the circuit. In a brushless motor, the rotor is made of magnets, while the stator is made of coils that are alternately positively and negatively charged. 

This causes the engine to turn as the poles attract and repel one another. The rotor and stator are kept apart from one another, which is an advantage. When two electromagnets are brought close to each other, the energy is transferred magnetically.

The motor is run by the alternating current generated by an electronic card that converts DC power into AC power at a configurable three-phase frequency. This results in a revolving field, which in turn causes the coils to spin. The current flowing through the motor is continuously adjusted by an electronic module either embedded inside the motor itself or housed separately from it.

Ultimately, this boosts efficiency and delivers substantial cost savings.